All-Time India XIs - A re-run

[Thala_0710]

I need Jaiswal to atleast score some runs away before placing him ahead of a batter arguably better at home.
Re quality gap, it's bigger; but variety is also huge boost for Kuldeep.

Yeah I agree with that, but that was my initial point about Axar and Kuldeep too, neither have done anything away from home either. For the international experience, it's mainly white ball cricket though, which doesn't necessarily translate to tests

 

[capt_Luffy]

Yeah I agree with that, but that was my initial point about Axar and Kuldeep too, neither have done anything away from home either

Well, Kuldeep has a 5 fifer. And they are competing with Harbhajan who was more bad than good more often. Ofcourse there is the 2001 BGT, but otherwise, he was mediocre most often.

 

[Thala_0710]

Well, Kuldeep has a 5 fifer. And they are competing with Harbhajan who was more bad than good more often. Ofcourse there is the 2001 BGT, but otherwise, he was mediocre most often.

Fair enough, no point in debating this further then. I do feel though Harbhajan is underrated here quite a bit

 

[capt_Luffy]

Fair enough, no point in debating this further then. I do feel though Harbhajan is underrated here quite a bit

I sometimes feel that too, for a bowler with 400+ scalps, he sure gets the short end of the stick. But Kuldeep is a gun though, who I am quite confident would had been a staple in the Indian side of not for Ash-Jadeja. He is just unlucky to play in the era where the Indian bowling is the strongest.

 

[centurymaker]

Vijay, Shastri, Harbhajan

 

[Line and Length]

Vijay, Shastri, Harbhajan

Ditto

 

[Fuller Pilch]

X3

 

[capt_Luffy]

X3

?? Do you meant you nominate those 3?

 

[capt_Luffy]

Navjot Singh Sidhu - 4
Murali Vijay - 4
Ravi Shastri - 2

Ravi Shastri - 4 (+2)
Dattu Phadkar - 2
Vijay Manjrekar - 2
Chandu Borde - 1
Dilip Sardesai - 1

Harbhajan Singh - 7
Axar Patel - 2
Kuldeep Yadav - 1

 

[capt_Luffy]

India XI	India A	India B	India C
1. SM Gavaskar	1. VSM Merchant	1. RG Sharma	1. G Gambhir
2. V Sehwag	2. MH Mankad	2. FM Engineer+	2
3. RS Dravid	3. CA Pujara	3. MB Amarnath	3. PR Umrigar
4. SR Tendulkar	4. VS Hazare	4. DB Vengsarkar	4. MAK Pataudi
5. V Kohli	5. GR Viswanath	5. M Azharuddin	5. AM Rahane
6. RR Pant+	6. VVS Laxman	6. SC Ganguly*	6. RJ Shastri
7. RR Jadeja	7. MS Dhoni+*	7. NB Amarnath	7. SMH Kirmani+
8. NK Dev*	8. A Kumble	8. LNA Singh	8. H Singh
9. R Ashwin	9. J Srinath	9. BS Bedi	9. UT Yadav
10. MA Shami	10. Z Khan	10. I Sharma	10. EAS Prasanna
11. JJ Bumrah	11. BS Chandrashekhar	11. S Gupte	11. M Nissar
India D
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Now please vote for:
A) One of Sidhu or Murali Vijay to open, if you haven't voted for either. You can also switch your vote of you want.
B) The captain of India C
C) Two opening bowlers for India D
D) One Middle order batsman
E) The wicketkeeper

 

[capt_Luffy]

Tiger Pataudi

Bhuvneshwar Kumar
Mohammad Siraj

Vijay Manjrekar

Wridhiman Saha

 

[Thala_0710]

Sidhu

Pataudi

Bhuvi
Siraj

Manjrekar

Saha

 

[Teuton]

Pataudi
Bhuvi
Siraj
V. Manjrekar
More

 

[Bitmap]

Tiger Pataudi

Bhuvneshwar Kumar
Mohammad Siraj

Vijay Manjrekar

Wridhiman Saha

+1

 

[Xix2565]

Murali Vijay to open

Pataudi

Bhuvi
Siraj

Chandu Borde

Wriddhiman Saha

 

[Fuller Pilch]

?? Do you meant you nominate those 3?

Yes.

 

[Fuller Pilch]

Murali Vijay

Pataudi

B Kumar
Siraj

Vijay Manrejkar

More

 

[capt_Luffy]

Navjot Singh Sidhu gets in off of Thala's vote (to clear things up, both Xix and FP voted Murali Vijay in the previous round as well, i.e., I have been counting their votes among the 4 Vijay votes)

MAK Pataudi - 6

Vijay Manjrekar - 5
Chandu Borde - 1

Bhuvneshwar Kumar - 6
Mohammad Siraj - 6

Wridhiman Saha - 4
Kiran More - 2

 

[capt_Luffy]

India XI	India A	India B	India C
1. SM Gavaskar	1. VSM Merchant	1. RG Sharma	1. G Gambhir
2. V Sehwag	2. MH Mankad	2. FM Engineer+	2 NS Sidhu
3. RS Dravid	3. CA Pujara	3. MB Amarnath	3. PR Umrigar
4. SR Tendulkar	4. VS Hazare	4. DB Vengsarkar	4. MAK Pataudi*
5. V Kohli	5. GR Viswanath	5. M Azharuddin	5. AM Rahane
6. RR Pant+	6. VVS Laxman	6. SC Ganguly*	6. RJ Shastri
7. RR Jadeja	7. MS Dhoni+*	7. NB Amarnath	7. SMH Kirmani+
8. NK Dev*	8. A Kumble	8. LNA Singh	8. H Singh
9. R Ashwin	9. J Srinath	9. BS Bedi	9. UT Yadav
10. MA Shami	10. Z Khan	10. I Sharma	10. EAS Prasanna
11. JJ Bumrah	11. BS Chandrashekhar	11. S Gupte	11. M Nissar
India D
1.
2.
3.
4.
5. VL Manjrekar
6.
7. W Saha+
8.
9. BS Kumar
10. M Siraj
11.