Cummins vs Bumrah

[HouHsiaoHsien]

Bumrah has a much higher ceiling than Cummins.

 

[Fuller Pilch]

Bumrah has a much higher ceiling than Cummins.

He needs a very high ceiling. If he had a low ceiling he'd hit it with his right arm whenever he practised bowling inside.

 

[Coronis]

Bumrah has a much higher ceiling than Cummins.

How silly. Cummins is like 14cm (5 inches) taller.

 

[ma1978]

I still maintain, Bumrah will struggle it seems to reach 300 wickets and Cummins will likely end up with the better career.

I see you’re moving the goalposts

Bumrah has 126 wickets away from home at 21.10

Cummins has 113 wickets away from home at 25.94

Since you don’t consider tests at home to be important, doesn’t Bunrah actually have a greater body of work at five points better average.

You can’t say tests at heme don’t matter for Ashwin and consider them relevant for Cummins or Bumrah.

 

[subshakerz]

Since you don’t consider tests at home to be important, doesn’t Bunrah actually have a greater body of work at five points better average.

You can’t say tests at heme don’t matter for Ashwin and consider them relevant for Cummins or Bumrah.

Lol that's a strawman. I did a whole thread about appreciating SC pacers at home, remember?

And I always maintained for myself, a modern ATG pacer needs 300 wickets as a test of output to qualify.

Hence even tho Bumrah is a better bowler, if he retired today I would rate Cummins ahead based on output.

 

[Shri]

Lol that's a strawman. I did a whole thread about appreciating SC pacers at home, remember?

no one remembers anything you have ever said you wet wipe of a human

 

[subshakerz]

Bumrah has everything. The only struggle now will be age and his back.

 

[ma1978]

Lol that's a strawman. I did a whole thread about appreciating SC pacers at home, remember?

And I always maintained for myself, a modern ATG pacer needs 300 wickets as a test of output to qualify.

Hence even tho Bumrah is a better bowler, if he retired today I would rate Cummins ahead based on output.

Cummins is Shami level away from Aus

 

[subshakerz]

Cummins is Shami level away from Aus

Sure. Bumrah is better at present but you need a minimum sample to judge someone as a great.

 

[ma1978]

Sure. Bumrah is better at present but you need a minimum sample to judge someone as a great.

You’re not judging someone as great, you’re judging who is better

 

[ma1978]

Sure. Bumrah is better at present but you need a minimum sample to judge someone as a great.

In any case your logic is ridiculous, why is home performance irrelevant for Ashwin and not for Bumrah

 

[subshakerz]

In any case your logic is ridiculous, why is home performance irrelevant for Ashwin and not for Bumrah

Translation: I am not biased against Bumrah.

 

[ma1978]

Translation: I am not biased against Bumrah.

Translation: You are a confused man.

 

[subshakerz]

Translation: You are a confused man.

Saying you need a minimum output isn't really confusing. You just disagree.

 

[ma1978]

Saying you need a minimum output isn't really confusing. You just disagree.

I believe you need a minimum output. I'm saying Bumrah has a minimum output already as far as away performance goes, and that's all you apparently care about

 

[Coronis]

Translation: you’re both idiots arguing on a cricket forum.