Better white ball bowler: Mitchell Starc or Glenn McGrath

[Saket1209]

Both Average in low 20s ,both are big tournament player but who will come out of the top between them.

 

[ashley bach]

One of these bowlers was miles better than the other.

 

[Adorable Asshole]

One of these bowlers was miles better than the other.

Not miles but still significantly better

 

[Spark]

One of these bowlers was miles better than the other.

This is obviously true but on performances alone it's not that straightforward a discussion tbf. 2015 WC Starc was as dominant a bowling performance in a WC as anyone had seen.

 

[ashley bach]

Not miles but still significantly better

An economy rate of 3.88 versus 5.11 is more than significant.

 

[Spark]

An economy rate of 3.88 versus 5.11 is more than significant.

Given the difference in what constitutes a decent score in 2000 vs 2020 it's not that signficant.

 

[ashley bach]

This is obviously true but on performances alone it's not that straightforward a discussion tbf. 2015 WC Starc was as dominant a bowling performance in a WC as anyone had seen.

Yeah Mitchell's certainly had some clutch moments, but overall, and with the differential of wickets taken and RPO, you just can't build a case that
Starc was better.

 

[halba]

Mcgrath easily.economy. mcgrath is top 3 in ODI best bowlers ever, and top 3 in tests.

 

[SillyCowCorner1]

Can we please close this thread.

This is the greatest disrespect to Mcgrath since this,

 

[Adorable Asshole]

Mcgrath easily.economy. mcgrath is top 3 in ODI best bowlers ever, and top 3 in tests.

Doubtful. Pollock, Garner and Wasim are better.

 

[Slifer]

Can we please close this thread.

This is the greatest disrespect to Mcgrath since this,

View attachment 36370

With all due respect, McGrath did this to himself.

 

[Kenneth Viljoen]

McGrath had batsmen SPOOKED

 

[Silver Line]

In Odis for me its

1. Brett Lee
2. Mitchell Starc
3. Glenn McGrath

Regardless a Stunning attack to have together, only Pakistan can level this if warne and saqlain as the spinners are considered too

 

[Socerer 01]

In Odis for me its

1. Brett Lee
2. Mitchell Starc
3. Glenn McGrath

Regardless a Stunning attack to have together, only Pakistan can level this if warne and saqlain as the spinners are considered too

galaxy brain take

 

[Silver Line]

Starc and Lee need a ball, McGrath needs a ball and fielders.

 

[Himannv]

Starc and Lee need a ball, McGrath needs a ball and fielders.

McGoat doesn't need no fielders.

 

[Adorable Asshole]

McGoat doesn't need no fielders.

Do keepers and slip not count as fielders?

 

[Silver Line]

McGoat doesn't need no fielders.

64% of his of his wickets are by ‘caught’.

the highest % by any odi bowler in history minimum 200 Wickets.

 

[Himannv]

Do keepers and slip don't count as fielders?

Members of the orchestra as the maestro crafts his masterpiece.

 

[Silver Line]

Members of the orchestra as the maestro crafts his masterpiece.

Thats an odd way to type McGrath needs fielders