• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Kohli’s India vs Imran’s Pakistan

Which was the better test team?


  • Total voters
    21

centurymaker

Cricketer Of The Year
Wellington 2020, how is scoring 165 and conceding a 180 run lead a par first innings performance.
WTC final was a farce since NZ had just played a series there. Plus it is more logical to blame Bumrah for going wicketless both innings, and Pant could have been more mature. Kohli also could have batted better.
That was a disgrace indeed. How on earth they allowed one team to play a series there... it was no longer a so-called 'neutral' final, also considering how they prepared a green top, which India batted 1st on. Everything was stacked in favor of one team by ECB, as a payback for robbing them of 2019 ODI WC title.
 

centurymaker

Cricketer Of The Year
I think it was silly that India did not try to play some series before the WTC in England. I am pretty sure they could have worked out deals with some counties and had SL or some other board who need the money over to play a couple of tests.
It just shouldn't be allowed. What's the point of having a neutral final in the first place if teams started doing that?
 

Daemon

Request Your Custom Title Now!
It just shouldn't be allowed. What's the point of having a neutral final in the first place if teams started doing that?
Nah, you can prepare however you want. Both sides had the opportunity to do so with ample notice.

It’s the richest board in the world against a team who makes losses on tests ffs.

What sucks is it’s always in England where no Asian side will have an advantage should they make it there.
 

centurymaker

Cricketer Of The Year
Nah, you can prepare however you want. Both sides had the opportunity to do so with ample notice.

It’s the richest board in the world against a team who makes losses on tests ffs.

What sucks is it’s always in England where no Asian side will have an advantage should they make it there.
It should never be in one location. Thats what further detracts from it. Already the matches and series are quite imbalanced. Big 3 are playing way more matches against quality opponents, while the rest are playing more matches vs the rest. Moreover, 1-2 teams get given an easy route to the final everytime. It's hardly a fair tournament tbh.

All teams should be playing each other in a 4 year window. Playing 6 teams out of 8 is not good enough. For example, South Africa is not playing Australia and England next time.

Even 7 out of 8 would be a lot better, if they can't play all.

Each series should be worth the same. At the moment, points are being given based on matches, which is so wrong imo. So WTC right now is worse than the other ICC WCs.
 

centurymaker

Cricketer Of The Year
Nah, you can prepare however you want. Both sides had the opportunity to do so with ample notice.

It’s the richest board in the world against a team who makes losses on tests ffs.

What sucks is it’s always in England where no Asian side will have an advantage should they make it there.
And there was no ample notice, teams only qualified in the final few months.

Shoud all teams anticipate (well in advance) that theyre going to make the final and arrange a test series in Eng for early June? It's just not possible dude.

And arranging a series last minute is difficult as well. NZ were fortunate that they were able to do it.

COVID also played a huge role last time as teams had to miss some series and thus were quite negatively impacted. All in all, WTC has been a mess so far. If they can't fix it, they should scrap it or have it over 4 years rather 2 years. At least the results will be more fair over a 4 year window.
 
Last edited:

Daemon

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Can’t imagine it’d be too difficult to organise a quick game with Ireland

Just do the groundwork in anticipation and scrap if you don’t make the finals (or go ahead regardless even)

These guys moved an entire IPL overseas at the last minute but this is too difficult? Give me a break.

At bare minimum send the players over earlier and play more tour games.
 

Daemon

Request Your Custom Title Now!
I’d say even after adequate preparation NZ would still have an inherent advantage because of conditions, just like India would if the game was in Delhi or something. That’s just too bad for India and a fault of their own making, but the advantage exists.
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
I’d say even after adequate preparation NZ would still have an inherent advantage because of conditions, just like India would if the game was in Delhi or something. That’s just too bad for India and a fault of their own making, but the advantage exists.
How is it a fault of their own making in that case though? You think BCCI should have arm twisted ICC to have it held in Dubai?
 

R!TTER

State Regular
Are people suddenly forgetting here what just preceded the finals? How the heck was BCCI going to do anything about WTC when it was peak Covid in India, FFS the IPL had to be cancelled/postponed midway. In fact had the pandemic not been brought slightly under control (in India) there wouldn't have been a final in the first place!
Can’t imagine it’d be too difficult to organise a quick game with Ireland

Just do the groundwork in anticipation and scrap if you don’t make the finals (or go ahead regardless even)

These guys moved an entire IPL overseas at the last minute but this is too difficult? Give me a break.

At bare minimum send the players over earlier and play more tour games.
Yeah no looks like you have no idea what you're talking about :laughing:

The WTC was a farce anyway because the conditions heavily favored one side, not just their prep but also that they didn't even play a spinner! Neutral venue my **** ?
 

Daemon

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Are people suddenly forgetting here what just preceded the finals? How the heck was BCCI going to do anything about WTC when it was peak Covid in India, FFS the IPL had to be cancelled/postponed midway. In fact had the pandemic not been brought slightly under control (in India) there wouldn't have been a final in the first place!
Yeah no looks like you have no idea what you're talking about :laughing:

The WTC was a farce anyway because the conditions heavily favored one side, not just their prep but also that they didn't even play a spinner! Neutral venue my **** ?
Why did you change emojis midway through your post?
 

Fuller Pilch

Hall of Fame Member
I agree with the examples you have given. But there are also examples where India under him performed well in crucial matches(tho none as crucial as WTC final). But if you look at the context at some of the matches you mentioned, India’s defeats(like SA 2022 third test) can’t be purely blamed on Kohli’s excessive intensity.
India overperformed in the WTC final. They managed to take NZ to the 6th day.
 

Daemon

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Are people suddenly forgetting here what just preceded the finals? How the heck was BCCI going to do anything about WTC when it was peak Covid in India, FFS the IPL had to be cancelled/postponed midway. In fact had the pandemic not been brought slightly under control (in India) there wouldn't have been a final in the first place!
Yeah no looks like you have no idea what you're talking about :laughing:

The WTC was a farce anyway because the conditions heavily favored one side, not just their prep but also that they didn't even play a spinner! Neutral venue my **** ?
Good point about the IPL being postponed actually (though not one in your favour).

IPL was originally scheduled to end around the first week of June, just 10 days or so before the WTC final. Perfect preparation and totally enough time to acclimatise for the final.

The fact that it was postponed was a blessing as it allowed the team a bit more time to rest and prepare.
 

R!TTER

State Regular
Not at all. Ajaz hardly plays and Santner wasn't in the final 15 man squad.
That's because NZ pitches have progressively become worse for spinners in the last 10-15 years! Among major test nations their reversal is probably the most striking.
Good point about the IPL being postponed actually (though not one in your favour).

IPL was originally scheduled to end around the first week of June, just 10 days or so before the WTC final. Perfect preparation and totally enough time to acclimatise for the final.

The fact that it was postponed was a blessing as it allowed the team a bit more time to rest and prepare.
Nope, the Covid cases started surging sometime around March & that went on for about 2-4 months. This led to strained resources throughout the country & in fact one of the major sticking point at the time was players getting multiple jabs in the IPL whilst the general public had to wait & many died as a result. Ashwin withdrew due to his family(immediate?) members getting infected & that had a domino effect throughout the tournament.

If the cases had not gone down around May/June it's possible some of the team members would not play the WTC final & not to mention there was a quarantine requirement(?) in UK at the time. Things had to stabilize in India first, otherwise WTC final would've been postponed. No way BCCI could justify this with the backlash they already faced for IPL & rightly so!
 

Top