• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Kapil Dev vs Ian Botham

Who was the greater test allrounder?

  • Kapil Dev

    Votes: 8 22.2%
  • Ian Botham

    Votes: 28 77.8%

  • Total voters
    36

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Jeez Clive Rice must have been a grand cricketer. Woild love to have seen him play a decent number of test matches.
 

h_hurricane

International Vice-Captain
Botham's career was two parts in stark contrast. The first half gave as much pleasure as mast**bation whereas the second half was like the pain in the d**k that followed.
 

AndrewB

International Vice-Captain
I was about to quibble about the late David Capel, but I thought I'd better check, and you're probably right. I had remembered his occasional triumphs and forgotten his overall test averages of 15.6 and 50.6, unfortunately with bat and ball respectively,.
Botham's averages in his last 5 years were 20.4 and 55.6.
The other pseudo-all-rounders (i.e. bowlers who the selectors may have hoped would score a few runs) in that 5-year spell were:
Phil Newport: 27.50, 41.70
Chris Lewis: 26.64, 35.61
Derek Pringle: 13.33, 34.86
Philip DeFreitas: 11.86, 30.54
and I guess you could include John Emburey: 31.23, 62.78
 

Jayro

U19 12th Man
Botham's averages in his last 5 years were 20.4 and 55.6.
The other pseudo-all-rounders (i.e. bowlers who the selectors may have hoped would score a few runs) in that 5-year spell were:
Phil Newport: 27.50, 41.70
Chris Lewis: 26.64, 35.61
Derek Pringle: 13.33, 34.86
Philip DeFreitas: 11.86, 30.54
and I guess you could include John Emburey: 31.23, 62.78
Craig White,
Dominic Cork,
Alex tudor,
Mark Elham,
Roni Irani,
Adam Hollioake,
Dermott Reeve?
England were desperate to find another Botham throughout the 90s and understandably, he was really that great when got going.
 

wpdavid

Hall of Fame Member
Botham's averages in his last 5 years were 20.4 and 55.6.
The other pseudo-all-rounders (i.e. bowlers who the selectors may have hoped would score a few runs) in that 5-year spell were:
Phil Newport: 27.50, 41.70
Chris Lewis: 26.64, 35.61
Derek Pringle: 13.33, 34.86
Philip DeFreitas: 11.86, 30.54
and I guess you could include John Emburey: 31.23, 62.78
Emburey's bowling average :ph34r:
 

AndrewB

International Vice-Captain
Craig White,
Dominic Cork,
Alex tudor,
Mark Elham,
Roni Irani,
Adam Hollioake,
Dermott Reeve?
England were desperate to find another Botham throughout the 90s and understandably, he was really that great when got going.
Also Ben Hollioake, who was about the only whose figures were worse than those of 1987-1992 Botham .

I don't think Tudor was picked as a prospective all-rounder - apart from his 99* as nightwatchman he never batted higher than 8 (and his batting average outside that Test was also 8). Cork was also usually batting at 8 or lower.
 

Top