• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official*** India in Australia 2014-5

Cevno

Hall of Fame Member
Yeah. But if we exclude the Johnson runs, I don't think Starc and Lyon would've got the runs they did. Johnson's innings just deflated us completely.
Yeah and that put extra mental pressure on our batsman too with which the Dhawan injury in the morning saw the collapse.

The complete collapse of bowlers and strategy in that tail wag was abysmal.
 

Tangles

International Vice-Captain
"Exclude the Johnson runs" meant from the tail-wag difference rather than the score - ie. even if we let the Johnson runs stand and India just didn't let Starc, Lyon and Hazlewood hammer them around, this could've been a real contest.
MJ took the momentum away from them and they never got it back.
 

anil1405

International Captain
Another case of Johnson's runs with the bat having a positive impact on his bowling. Letting this guy score runs is a disaster.
 

Prince EWS

Global Moderator
I've been a massive Watson fan for a very long time.. probably only second to dontcloseyoureyes on that front.. but I really just have no faith in his batting anymore. I'd love to make the usual arguments about Australia's batting depth being weak, or him adding more as the fifth bowler than a specialist batsman who'd only be roughly as good as him anyway, but I don't even buy it myself anymore. He hasn't even been scoring as well in one dayers of late. He should be under serious pressure if Mitch Marsh is fit.
 

Cabinet96

Hall of Fame Member
Sorry, but even if Dhawan was fit Kohli could've been facing the second ball of the day. Should've been prepared to bat regardless.
 

dognutz

U19 12th Man
Well done Aussies but a funny ole game that one. It was hard to gauge at times how much poor performances were induced by pressure and how much good performances were enabled by poor opposition. I'm referring to both sides of course
 
Last edited:

JBMAC

State Captain
So, in the end a relatively comfortable win for the Aussies. Smith deservedly MOM.Possibly Hazlewood unlucky in this respect.

As for changes for Melbourne, Watson has to go Mitch Marsh has to prove his fitness, Warner has to prove his as well, Haddin should go Wade come in.Who do you drop to bring in Harris. Johnson too inconsistent to be classed as an all-rounder.It will be interesting as to what the team is composed of.


There is probably a few names to be bandied about....eg Finch, Vogues, Maddison even Burns.
I would not to be a selector for quids
 

morgieb

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Warner 3 - not his best, but he was due and his thumb injury probably didn't help in the second innings.
Rogers 7 - two important 50's, second one ensured the chase went relatively smoothly.
Watson 4 - bowled well but he should be under a lot of pressure to keep his spot as a specialist batsman if Marsh is fit.
Smith 9 - **** me he's in good touch.
S Marsh 4 - meh. Two starts but didn't do anything with them.
M Marsh 4 - was bowling well before injury. Didn't do a lot with the bat.
Haddin 5 - great game with the gloves, but his batting is awful ATM. Shades of Healy circa 1999.
Johnson 8 - first innings was probably the worst he's bowled since he got back in the team. But his batting and spell in the first session today was utterly crucial. Is he back in the groove?
Starc 5 - fun batting, good bowling second dig despite his first innings efforts.
Lyon 6 - resonable bowling, joined in on the GOAT tail wag.
Hazlewood 8 - fun slog at the end and a debut 5-fer. Great debut, has a long future ahead of him.

Vijay 9 - well batted.
Dhawan 7 - tried his hardest second dig, particularly given he was allegedly hurt.
Pujara 4 - failed to kick on from a solid position in both innings.
Kohli 2 - let down after the glory of the previous Test.
Rahane 7 - well batted first dig but needs to stop playing dire shots before he's set.
R Sharma 3 - got a start first dig.
Dhoni 5 - kept OK barring a crucial drop, got a start first dig.
Ashwin 5 - can bat, bowling was not great.
Yadav 5.5 - bowled with fire at times, fun slog second dig.
Aaron 3 - unlucky yes but is still horribly inconsistent.
I Sharma 5 - bowled very well at times but despite getting a lot more wickets was probably worse here than at Adelaide.
 

Top