Rishi Dhawan has a massive fan following- not surprisingly, Irfan Pathan did earlier. Seam bowling all-rounders, doing very well in Indian domestic events. Fans love them. It's a pity there are not too many. In the current scenario, Bhuvneshwar Kumar would be ideally better than Dhawan, since he's done well against top-tier (and later middle-tier) teams, and has maintained good records in ODs as well, and eventually became an ODI regular- but the brazen demolition in Jo'burg has shown him up to be small, slow and limited heavily- and the wrong choice for a strike bowler. I'm not sure he can even play for India after this series. The other option was Ashish Reddy, but both he and his team (Hyderabad) are in such dire straits, it makes no sense backing them. Abhishek Nayar is not an option- he barely bowls. Rajat Bhatia is an option, but he's no strike bowler, and India won't get green-tops all the time. Laxmi Ratan Shukla hits the deck hard and moves the ball well, but poor form in the recent season won't help. And the former fan favourite Irfan Pathan is struggling to stay fit.
In the spin all-rounder camp, we already have Ashwin, and the people running the team think they have one in Jadeja. This half is a lot more promising, but I'd be wary of giving Parvez Rassool an India cap due to lack of experience. Iqbal Abdulla is a neat OD bowler, but if he can't play for Mumbai, how can he play for India? Bipul Sharma is doing well for HP, ironically, Rishi Dhawan's team, but he's doing a lot less with the ball than needed, in terms of overs. Yusuf Pathan, unfit, out of form and out of favour, has had an upswing only recently, at his home ground, Moti Bagh- where his statistics are massively better than in the rest of India.