• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Cricketers who are really nice

DJellett

International Debutant
Really don't know how you could justify this opinion tbh.
Simply by the sheer fact that it is an opinion would perhaps be enough - though I have fairly significant experience in analysing an individual's character; and my exposure to Gilchrist indicates, to me at least, the characteristics, sentiments and judgements expressed above.
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
I thought so too, until the Sydney Test of the tour he captained here. Diabolical hypocrisy.
Ponting and Co. deserved that.. Kumble is a genuinely nice guy with a real passion for the game, as seen in him taking up the less glamorous and more fight-the-red-tapey administrative role with the KSCA.. Top Bloke.. Warney was amazingly real nice to us in Chennai the two or three times he played here.. Lara was a great bloke and if Gilly gets points for being a walker, Lara should get double for NOT being holier-than-thou about it and just carrying it on for an entire career in a matter-of-fact manner, unlike Gilly who only seemed to discover that walking was good from the 2003 WC..
 

Red

The normal awards that everyone else has
Do you think walking makes someone a better guy than someone who doesn't walk?

I reckon umpires are paid to make decisions. I've played plenty of games where I've been given out LBW when I've edged it on to my pad, or I know I haven't edged it and I've been given out caught behind.

I don't think there's anything wrong with not walking. There's an umpire there to make the decisions, I say let them make them. Then cop the good with the bad.
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
No.. I don't think staying on for the umpire's decision is bad at all.. But the ones who dont walk have no right to complain when they are given a bad decision.. I have a lot more respect for Sachin than say, a Steve Waugh, for that reason...
 

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Ponting and Co. deserved that.. Kumble is a genuinely nice guy with a real passion for the game, as seen in him taking up the less glamorous and more fight-the-red-tapey administrative role with the KSCA.. Top Bloke.. Warney was amazingly real nice to us in Chennai the two or three times he played here.. Lara was a great bloke and if Gilly gets points for being a walker, Lara should get double for NOT being holier-than-thou about it and just carrying it on for an entire career in a matter-of-fact manner, unlike Gilly who only seemed to discover that walking was good from the 2003 WC..
Nah, previous series he'd given the most God awful spray and send off to Mohammad Yousuf, then came here and preached about the spirit of cricket.

You can reasonably do either one, but not both.
 

benchmark00

Request Your Custom Title Now!
lol at people trying to rubbish Adam Gilchrist. One of the nicest people, not just cricketer, I've ever met.
 
Last edited:

BoyBrumby

Englishman
lol at people trying to rubbish Adam Gilchrist. One of the nicest person, not just cricketer, I've ever met.
Yeah, genuinely humble chap (where he has every case to be a conceited ****) and patently loves the game too, sort of bloke who seems as if he'd be happy to pay to watch the sport still. I don't ever recall him being sanctimonious about his walking either; saw it as a personal choice. In fact, I doubt he ever mentioned it except where he was asked outright.

Shaun Pollock seems a good egg too, although (apparently) some of this Twatter posts are a little churchy.
 

stumpski

International Captain
Surprised at the lack of mentions of Boycott, Botham and Pietersen tbh. :p


Possibly because he was never a superstar of the game, Vic Marks has always struck me as someone I'd like to have a beer or two with after the game. Generally some good banter on TMS with him and Aggers.
 

benchmark00

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Walking debate stepped up - Cricket - www.theage.com.au

This is the event which mostly comes to mind. Definitely takes him down a couple of notches in my eyes. I'm sure he's a great guy anyway, there's not many people out there who don't get a bit prickish about their opinions sometimes.
How was he being a prick? McMillan is a known ****head who has had plenty to say to many opposition players over the years, Gilchrist mentioned that he should have walked to try and put some guilt in his mind, obviously worked.

Gilchrist has said time and time and time again that he doesn't care if people don't walk. He has no problems with his team mates not walking, it's just a choice of his to walk. He's not saying he's better than people who don't walk.
 
Last edited:

fredfertang

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
How was he being a prick? McMillan is a known ****head who has had plenty to say to many opposition players over the years, Gilchrist mentioned that he should have walked to try and put some guilt in his mind, obviously worked.

Gilchrist has said time and time and time again that he doesn't care if people don't walk. He has no problems with his team mates not walking, it's just a choice of his to walk. He's not saying he's better than people who don't walk.
Doesn't alter the fact that he is though - One of the frustrating things about that Australian side was that there weren't too many of them that it was easy to detest, and with Gilchrist it was well nigh impossible - only Hayden was totally without any redeeming features
 

Top