• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official New Zealand Domestic Season Thread 2009/10

straw man

Hall of Fame Member
Overrated perhaps? He was less then impressive in India, and we've all heard how he's one of the quicker bowlers in this comp, yet he was only bowling around 130-135K.
Yeah I saw a bit of that - was the first time I'd seen Wagner bowl and I was expecting something a bit different tbh. Not that that means anything necessarily - like Athlai says a few games off-colour doesn't prove anything and will see how he goes the rest of the season.

He only needs to come good in about 18 months time anyway ;)
 

straw man

Hall of Fame Member
Fulton gets his hundred.

Have to say, of the domestic bullies I still have a soft spot for Sinclair, Cumming and Fulton and sometimes convince myself against my better judgment that they might do ok if given just one more chance. Whereas I really am sure I don't want Bell or Papps near the black caps again, ever.
 

Prince EWS

Global Moderator
I don't know where Cumming gets his reputation as a domestic bully from. He's done about as well as you'd expect at Test level for someone who averaged 36 in First Class cricket IMO. Fulton averages 44 and Sinclair averages almost 49 (which itself is deflated a bit by his 32 Tests).

Cumming's a good domestic player and he had a great 2008/09 season but unlike Sinclair and Fulton, it's a matter of just not being good enough rather than not being able to convert his performances to Test level. He's just been solid for Canterbury/Otago for ages - he's had good seasons and bad ones.
 
Last edited:

straw man

Hall of Fame Member
I don't know where Cumming gets his reputation as a domestic bully from. He's done about as well as you'd expect at Test level for someone who averaged 36 in First Class cricket IMO. Fulton averages 44 and Sinclair averages almost 49 (which itself is deflated a bit by his 32 Tests).

Cumming's a good domestic player and he had a great 2008/09 season but unlike Sinclair and Fulton, it's a matter of just not being good enough rather than not being able to convert his performances to Test level. He's just been solid for Canterbury/Otago for ages - he's had good seasons and bad ones.
Am mainly calling Cumming a domestic bully based on the last couple of seasons where I thought he'd really piled on the runs. However looked up his record and was surprised that he'd been pretty poor for a couple of seasons prior to the last one when he averaged 65. Of course his international matches are included in his season-by-season record below so would drag down his average a lot for some of those seasons.

Archive & Stats

IMO he'll probably average 50+ again this season (has certainly started pretty well) and I tend to think he's reached that plateau that the other players mentioned have where he has the experience, confidence and familiarity to slap around most of the domestic bowlers in NZ conditions. As well as scoring runs he's been doing it fairly quickly and therefore I'm assuming, more easily. Just like Papps, Bell, Sinclair and Fulton often do. Therefore IMO is reaching big-fish-in-small-pond status and is graduating as a domestic bully :)
 

Flem274*

123/5
Will be interesting seeing how Otago go when it's their turn to bat against Bond and Martin. They don't have Cumming for this match but do have Broom and B McCullum back. Redmond is injured. Even though Canterbury are doing well on this pitch I have a feeling Otago are going to struggle.

By the way, Wagner doesn't seem to be doing so well so far this season.
Its only the second match

How good are Northern Districts. Even when missing our two best bowlers we can destroy a batting line-up like CD's, easily the best domestic team in the country (this year).

Hopefully our top order fires this time, I'm not to worried about this bowling attack though, it's pretty tame.

And how long do CD persist with Worker, he's never really done anything at this level.
ND are pretty good at bowling. Pity their batting includes the likes of James Marshall and Michael Parlane. :p

Though unfortunately they also happen to have Kane Williamson, damn them.
 

DIRK-NANNES

U19 Vice-Captain
He was less then impressive in India, and we've all heard how he's one of the quicker bowlers in this comp, yet he was only bowling around 130-135K.
Wagner's always been a just below/touching 140K bowler. Suppose I'm not one of those 'all' people :tongue:, I don't recall him being noted as a speed demon.

He scored a 100 for NZ A didn't he? Or maybe it was for the Emerging team.
Yeah he did get one for the Emerging Players, although it was only a 2-day match so it doesn't have FC status.
Tour Match: New Zealand Emerging Players v England Lions at Lincoln, Feb 22-23, 2009 | Cricket Scorecard | Cricinfo.com
 

Howsie

International Captain
Wagner's always been a just below/touching 140K bowler. Suppose I'm not one of those 'all' people :tongue:, I don't recall him being noted as a speed demon.
Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm fairly certain Matthew Sinclair said on here that he was the fastest bowler going around domestic cricket?
 

Howsie

International Captain
Its only the second match



ND are pretty good at bowling. Pity their batting includes the likes of James Marshall and Michael Parlane. :p

Though unfortunately they also happen to have Kane Williamson, damn them.
Bowling's far and away our strength, but most people seem to think we would stuggle to chase down 100 if needed too. Wilson, Marshall, Parlane, Williamson and Flynn when he gets back (can't see him playing too much international cricket this year) is more then good enough.
 

Flem274*

123/5
Pretty sure it was McClenaghan who said Wagner was one of the quickest in the country.

Tbh him being one of the quickest here isn't all that surprising considering that bowlers that can hit 140 are considered rather nippy here. The only genuinely quick bowlers we have are Shane Bond, Mitchell McClenaghan, possibly Te Ahu Davis (not sure how much pace injury stole from him) and possibly Sherlock (see Davis).

Then below that lot would be Mark Gillespie in his own category of being able to bowl anywhere from 125kph to 145kph (remembering his test debut in SA where the commentators were surprised at the speed gun readings from him).

Then guys like Iain O'Brien, Chris Martin, Neil Wagner, Ian Butler and possibly Hamish Bennett can hit the low 140s when they really crank it (Last I saw of Bennett was a couple of seasons ago at most, can't recall much).
 

Polo23

International Debutant
Bennett was bloody quick last time I saw him, but haven't seen him in ages and he's hardly played so I have no idea how quick he is now.

Would be interesting to see what kind of speeds Boult is bowling, wouldn't be surprised if he was up around 140km/h.
 

Flem274*

123/5
Bennett was bloody quick last time I saw him, but haven't seen him in ages and he's hardly played so I have no idea how quick he is now.

Would be interesting to see what kind of speeds Boult is bowling, wouldn't be surprised if he was up around 140km/h.
Dunno, he's not an overly big guy, though I think an article that someone industrious posted said he'd bulked up.
 

Top