By Indians, I also implied Indian fans! The cricketers have the option of skipping the tourneys, if they want to [not that they will because of the money]. I didn't read the comment that you provided but I would assume that if Dhoni complained it's because he wants better planing of tournaments and that necessarily doesn't mean that he wants IPL or T20 skipped [like you are making it appear].
If your point is that Dhoni complained of over cricket so IPL [or T20] is the reason then you could possible looking at the wrong angle. It could also mean that he wants better rotation, proper scheduling, etc.
I wasn't trying to imply that Dhoni made those comments because he had preference to T20s over Test or ODI's. If my memory serves me corrected didn't Dhoni skip the tour the SRI because of fatigue?, then the series vs AUS & ENG where really clustured.
He made that intial comment during the ODI series vs ENG & the BCCI cautioned him. Now fast-forward to the T20 WC he took the approach to say "Fatigue is part of Indian cricket" so as to avoid problem with the BCCI.
Rotation should not even be an option really. Too much cricket is being played already, its a problem in the modern game with all players that they have to skip games because of fatigue - It drops the standard of internationals. How do you think the paying fans would feel if going to some games means missing out seeing stars?
The GENERAL point & problem though is. The fear of player burn-out in the FTP & a total lack of control over the spread of these T20 tournaments due to the poor ICC structure - is causing talks of players probably going for T20 riches over international honours. This is a MASSIVE problem.
the point is if they want to chose what they want to play then let them. who are you to decide what they should be playing and what they shouldn't? why it should be considered wrong if they feel the need to focus on T20 more as a career strategy?
Hold this has nothing to do with ME & what i want. So clear those cob-webs...
My goodness are you serious?. Test cricket is a ultimate version of cricket, the lack of control over the growth of T20 cricket has i'm saying is dangerous for the future of test cricket, if young players see T20 has their prefered option in cricket instead of tests. Why is this even a debate?
4 international player restriction means that 7 Indian players play! And we all know that you learn more by first hand playing experience, by actually being on the field in that kind of environment, with pressure [including crowd]
Just to clear up, i am not againts the player restrictions. India brought up the idea & they are funding it. But the problem with the IPL as i keep saying is - given the ICC really isn't structure as the "Governing body" of world cricket - and the BCCI indirectly holds that positions. They really didn't have to go to anybody superior when they announced this tournament for approval.
Under a proper ICC, a proper concession should have been made between them & the BCCI between the Int'l player rules restrictions vs Indian players, because the IPL needs to international players as you rightfully claim to help those Indian players, since it would be useless.
I would have suggested maybe 5/6 international players could play per game. But that doesn't mean ALL 5/6 have to play per game. You have 14 group games right, so rotation could happen & the Indian players would still get the exposure
If Modi & company didn't want to comply to those "probable rules" a strong ICC would suggest, the IPL should not have been created, since the tournamnet has too much of an Indian biased towards it. Which is not in the interest of the global cricket community.
One has to learn to grow up to the times. In my opinion, there have been too many international tours which is causing many to lose interest in many of the tours as series follow after series. I think it's time to better schedule international cricket and that's what cricketers are probably suggesting too [and that's why they probably said that if that doesn't happen they will be forced to chose where they can better leverage their skills and career strategy]
Agree 100%. Player burn-out has become increasing a problem in this 2000s era. Thats why the lack of control over the these T20 tournaments with the money temptation is their can destroy the game.
Tournaments like the Champions trophy has to go & 7-match ODI series.
If as i was saying the IPL was created under such a knee-jerk basis of the T20 WC in SA 07, but instead as the one major, annual T20 global tournament outside of the World Cup T20. Players would not even be comtemplating retiring to T20 tournaments.