• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official Australia in India***

irfan

State Captain
Cameron White ball tampering? I just find the notion of him doing it hilarious. What's he trying to do - reverse swing his long hops? :p
 

Precambrian

Banned
If the loose piece was on the "rough" side of the ball, then he should be penalised by his own teammates for peeling it off as it would only aid reverse swing

Sounds like a total non-issue
Oh really? How thats a non-issue? Just because the effect wouldnt probably help Aus? FFS
 

IndGunner

First Class Debutant
Right, he may not mean it, but the stupidity of it should merit a punishment, esp after Ponting was warned by umpires before that for "cleaning' the ball without assistance of umpires.
Im guessing its just likely dravid accidentally put his cough lolly on the ball?
 

Demolition Man

State Vice-Captain
If the loose piece was on the "rough" side of the ball, then he should be penalised by his own teammates for peeling it off as it would only aid reverse swing

Sounds like a total non-issue
Pretty much. But will not stop people trying to ping an Aussie for ball tampering. Ludicrous, especially when players from certain countries have long histories of doing funky things with the ball, hang on a sec......
some people wouldn;t be trying to give the aussies a "taste of their own medicine"
 
Last edited:

Precambrian

Banned
Pretty much. But will not stop people trying to ping an Aussie for ball tampering. Ludicrous, especially when players from certain countries have long histories of doing funky things with the ball, hang on a sec......
some people wouldn;t be trying to give the aussies a "taste of their own medicine"
Whinge.
 

duffer

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Pretty much. But will not stop people trying to ping an Aussie for ball tampering. Ludicrous, especially when players from certain countries have long histories of doing funky things with the ball, hang on a sec......
some people wouldn;t be trying to give the aussies a "taste of their own medicine"
:laugh:

Oh dear.
 

social

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Oh really? How thats a non-issue? Just because the effect wouldnt probably help Aus? FFS
You do realise that if White took the ball to the umpire then he would probably remove the offending piece himself?

And just how would "smoothing" out a rough area on the rough side of the ball help Oz?:wacko:

Also, if by some chance the offending piece was on the "smooth" side of the ball, then all he needed to do was rub persperation into the area and rub it on his pants, i.e SHINE IT!!!!!! and the thing would stay down (if you dont believe, head down to the nets and try it)

If you want blood, fine him for doing the umps job but calling that ball tampering is making the quintessential mountain out of nothing
 

alternative

Cricket Web Content Updater
Will do.

But saying someone who took a loose bit of material off the ball should be done for ball tampering simply is not in the spirit of the game and I would expect better from true cricket fans.
Being a professional cricketer, White should have known better, so i don't think he should be easily let off for that.

Anyway, well here is what the law actually states:

Players are barred, by Law 42.3, from rubbing the ball on the ground, interfering with its seam or surface, or using any implement that can alter the condition of the ball to thereby gain unfair advantage.
 

FaaipDeOiad

Hall of Fame Member
Jesus, seems like I missed a lot, forgot to put the cricket on to record before I went out today too.

Watto got some wickets, Ponting bowled part-timers to up the over rate when the game was on the line, and White might be in trouble for ball tampering? I'll try and catch the highlights in the morning.

Anyway, my tip for tomorrow is that Australia will get off to a good start, then India will go on the defensive and a few quick wickets will fall. Draw in the end.
 

IndGunner

First Class Debutant
Jesus, seems like I missed a lot, forgot to put the cricket on to record before I went out today too.

Watto got some wickets, Ponting bowled part-timers to up the over rate when the game was on the line, and White might be in trouble for ball tampering? I'll try and catch the highlights in the morning.

Anyway, my tip for tomorrow is that Australia will get off to a good start, then India will go on the defensive and a few quick wickets will fall. Draw in the end.
Going out on a limb eh :P
 

Matt79

Hall of Fame Member
Moving on from the drama, how fricken awesome is it that Watson finally delivered in spades with the ball in a Test? Wrapped for him to be the key bowler - and honestly for Johnson to have got none in this innings, as he's consistently bowled better than Mitch IMO without any of Johnson's luck through the series. Sucks massively that the overrate thing stopped Ponting from lettimg Watto bowl us to a winnable position.

Great for Krejza as well to follow up his 8 with another 4 today. At least one thing out of this series is that now have a clear indication as to who our first choice spinner is - if he fails that one thing, but at least we hopefully have some direction on what the plan is - Krejza should be in if we are to play a spinner, until someone makes a better case. And given the over rate drama in this game, I can't see Ponting or the selectors plumping for a 4 quick strategy. (Although what they'll probably do is drop White for Symonds and make Haddin bat at 8). (Although actually, given the selectorial nous displayed this series, they'll dump Krejza, keep White, and then make Hayden bowl the majority of the slow stuff).
 
Last edited:

Top