vic_orthdox
Global Moderator
Stiff on Bailey.I'd dare suggest that none of the above 4 will ever pull on a baggy green cap unless they show a lot more improvement.
Stiff on Bailey.I'd dare suggest that none of the above 4 will ever pull on a baggy green cap unless they show a lot more improvement.
Gosh, how did I forget Haddin?Except that wouldn't be the team....
Haddin, Bracken, Hilfenhaus, and one of White, Voges or D Hussey would be in the team ahead of Ronchi, Kaspa, Bichel & possibly Lehman.
You reckon? I mean he's not even making the South Australian team atm (I'm assuming we're talking about Cullen Bailey )Stiff on Bailey.
I was thinking of George Bailey for some reasonYou reckon? I mean he's not even making the South Australian team atm (I'm assuming we're talking about Cullen Bailey )
Well most of us have missed you, that's for certain. Your popping-up for 1 post every 3 months has caused angst only because of that.To be honest, I'm rather enjoying the fact that my popping up now and again appears to be causing you angst. If it's any consolation, I wouldn't be so honest with someone I didn't like.
Okay fine, I may be around a bit more. Missed the place.
Whenever they're moving slowly enough to be worth keeping track of TBH. I'll be gone (from this one at least) when the Tests start and there are 50 posts per hour.Incidentally, since when did you post in *Official* threads?
Nah, it was George Bailey named in Aus B team, I think.You reckon? I mean he's not even making the South Australian team atm (I'm assuming we're talking about Cullen Bailey )
AWTA. Judging by the masses of posts during matches, I actually thought I was the only person on here who didn't seem to watch cricket while sitting at his computer typing comments into the thread. Glad to see there's at least one other.Whenever they're moving slowly enough to be worth keeping track of TBH. I'll be gone (from this one at least) when the Tests start and there are 50 posts per hour.
I read this stuff all the time, but end of the day your just looking at a side on paper and say they should be gun and dominate. I can see fair few holes in the side and potentially even an average A side could take advantage of.It depends if the selectors were picking the Australia A team for development, or to beat the other sides. If they were trying to be the best A team in the world, they'd do it easily, as they've got some big stars still playing domestic cricket.
Rogers
di Venuto
Katich
Hodge
Lehmann
Watson
Haddin (wk)
Bichel
Noffke
Gillespie
Kasprowicz
That team would dish out a a hiding to every other A team in the world.
Aus A were white washed 5-0 by Pak A in PakI reckon your wrong. Name a few other countries A sides who are better..
Maharoof is a bowler he's bound to take wickets. He's not so bad either.
Really, I didn't know about that, you should start a threadAus A were white washed 5-0 by Pak A in Pak
Pakistan A are better in 50 over cricket and I feel that India A are stronger in both forms of the game.I reckon your wrong. Name a few other countries A sides who are better.
You could pick holes in any team, but I'm saying that this Australia A team would be able to beat the 'A' sides of every other nation.I read this stuff all the time, but end of the day your just looking at a side on paper and say they should be gun and dominate. I can see fair few holes in the side and potentially even an average A side could take advantage of.
- Rogers has been on a couple A Tours and hadn't really dominated yet, been above par at best.
- Di Venuto might have a pretty good overall record. But if you look closer his had about 3 good seasons in Australia out of over 10 years. Only one as opener as well.
- Katich i rate pretty highly and has improved since he was dropped, but there was a reason for his below par Test record.
- When was the last time Hodge scored any runs, yeah class is greater then form, but still.
- Lehmann this season looks like his really on the decline. Had no pre season and his last innings was pretty good. But how many runs has he got left in him.
- Watson yeah gun batsmen, but will he be an effective bowling even at A level especially with no spinner in the side. You really need all your bowling options to take wickets if the pitch has little support for seamers.
- Haddin yeah he's class, but a reckon he would only have limited success at a higher level. Enough to be one of better keeper batsmen, but not really enough to have a dominate side unless you have a really dominate top 6.
- Bichel and Kaspra have just comeback from injury. They looked pretty good in the tour match, but Maharoof looked World Class, which says something about the pitch. Will they be as good as they once where?
- Gillespie bowling looks to be on the decline a fair bit, even at domestic (FC) level with a lack of zip. English, Australian and Pakistani batsmen have played him fairly easier in the last 9 months.
- Noffke in form, but he didn't look that great in the last A series from all reports. Better then average compared to say the Pakistan seamer, but not really World class
On paper a good side, that might dominate and might beat most Test side. But its also a side with a fair few looks that a decent players at A level might make the most of.