• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Which team's alltime XI is best?

Which alltime XI would enjoy the most success against its counterparts?


  • Total voters
    97

adharcric

International Coach
Hmm, I'm going by majority vote so right now it's just Hayden for Morris. The action starts in exactly five minutes.
 
Last edited:

adharcric

International Coach
West Indies in Australia - 2nd Test - Perth

Code:
[CENTER]West Indies 1st Innings[/CENTER]

CG Greenidge      lbw                 b McGrath        	 2 (6)
CC Hunte          c Gilchrist         b Lillee         	63 (128)
IVA Richards      c Warne             b Miller         	28 (58)
GA Headley                            b Miller         	23 (27)
BC Lara           st Gilchrist        b Warne          	 6 (8)
GS Sobers         c Gilchrist         b Warne          	 1 (10)
CL Walcott        lbw                 b McGrath        	52 (108)
MD Marshall                           b McGrath        	17 (43)
MA Holding        lbw                 b Miller         	 2 (18)
CEL Ambrose                           b McGrath        	 8 (17)
J Garner                              not out            2 (5)
Extras		  (w8 nb2 lb15)		                25
Total             72 overs	                       229 all out

Fall of wickets:
1-2  2-76  3-106  4-117  5-127  6-166  7-208  8-218  9-226  10-229  

Bowling Figures for Australia

                O	M	 R	W
McGrath        19	1	53	4	
Lillee         13	1	45	1	
Lindwall       14	2	54	0	
Miller         12	2	39	3	
Warne          13	4	23	2	

[CENTER]Australia 1st Innings[/CENTER]

VT Trumper        c Walcott           b Marshall       	19 (34)
ML Hayden         c Hunte             b Ambrose       	10 (11)
DG Bradman        c Walcott           b Garner          60 (104)
GS Chappell       c Hunte             b Marshall       	 0 (3)
RN Harvey         c Greenidge         b Ambrose       	81 (154)
KR Miller         c Walcott           b Ambrose       	17 (39)
AC Gilchrist                          not out           84 (162)
SK Warne          c Walcott           b Marshall       	20 (43)
RR Lindwall       c Hunte             b Holding        	22 (63)
DK Lillee         hit wkt             b Ambrose       	12 (28)
GD McGrath        c Richards          b Ambrose       	 0 (2)
Extras		  (w3 nb2 b8 lb9)		        22
Total             108 overs	                       347 all out

Fall of wickets:
1-25  2-43  3-43  4-150  5-195  6-213  7-263  8-322  9-347  10-347  

Bowling Figures for West Indies

                  O	M	 R	W
Marshall         25	6	83	3	
Ambrose          23	5	70	5	
Holding          17	2	66	1	
Garner           21	7	48	1	
Sobers           21	5	63	0	

[CENTER]West Indies 2nd Innings[/CENTER]

CG Greenidge                          b McGrath        	  0 (2)
CC Hunte          lbw                 b Lindwall       	102 (194)
IVA Richards      c Gilchrist         b Lillee         	  4 (6)
GA Headley                            b Lillee         	 16 (16)
BC Lara           c Gilchrist         b Lillee         	 98 (164)
GS Sobers         c Hayden            b McGrath        	 71 (133)
CL Walcott        c Chappell          b Lindwall       	108 (208)
MD Marshall                           run out            11 (36)
MA Holding        c Trumper           b Warne          	  4 (3)
CEL Ambrose       c Gilchrist         b Lindwall       	  9 (39)
J Garner                              not out             8 (18)
Extras		  (w6 nb1 b13 lb18)		         38
Total             137 overs	                        469 all out

Fall of wickets:
1-0  2-9  3-33  4-226  5-249  6-391  7-418  8-422  9-442  10-469  

Bowling Figures for Australia

                O	M	 R	W
McGrath        28	5      102	2	
Lillee         28	8	88	3	
Lindwall       29	6	92	3	
Miller         16	3	57	0	
Warne          35	8	99	1	

[CENTER]Australia 2nd Innings[/CENTER]
 
VT Trumper        c Walcott        b Marshall       	 7 (18)
ML Hayden         c Greenidge      b Ambrose       	 5 (5)
DG Bradman        c Greenidge      b Holding        	33 (49)
GS Chappell                        b Marshall       	 0 (1)
RN Harvey                          b Holding        	22 (66)
KR Miller         c Walcott        b Holding        	23 (46)
AC Gilchrist      c Hunte          b Garner          	 5 (6)
SK Warne          c Headley        b Garner          	 7 (9)
RR Lindwall       c Headley        b Garner          	 4 (15)
DK Lillee         lbw              b Holding        	 0 (16)
GD McGrath                         not out               0 (3)
Extras		  (w8 b11 lb1)		                20
Total             39 overs	                       126 all out

Fall of wickets:
1-12  2-14  3-14  4-73  5-89  6-98  7-118  8-118  9-126  10-126  

Bowling Figures for West Indies

                O	M	 R	W
Marshall       13	4	36	2	
Ambrose         7	0	28	1	
Holding        12	2	30	4	
Garner          7	3	20	3	

[B]West Indies won by 225 runs[/B]
[B]West Indies lead 2-0[/B]
Man of the match: Conrad Hunte
 

Matt79

Hall of Fame Member
Jeebus, a spanking by the Windies. Predictable perhaps with that quartet of bowlers on a WACA wicket, but jeez the Aussies crumpled in the 4th innings. Chappell got a pair and Hayden did little to justify the dumping of Morris. Whither the Aussies now one wonders... Can we call up Bobby Simpson to open with Trumper?
 

Matt79

Hall of Fame Member
Hopefully the Melbourne and Sydney pitches might be more enjoyable for Warne (our one real comparative advantage).

The openers are a concern. I thought Morris was dropped too soon, and I'd be tempted to bring him back to partner Trumper.

Having just annointed Chappell as the clear 2nd behind Bradman in terms of Australian batsmen in the other thread, can we now turn around and dump him? I'd think we'd best give him one more shot at redemption before swinging the axe.
 

Slifer

International Captain
I cant say im surprised at the result in the Perth test given the history between the 2 sides at that ground. That being said i do expect Australia to come roaring back in the next few tests. Would go with the same WI lineup (i dont believe in changing a winning combo) as for the Aussies well definitely for the Sydney test i would bring in an extra spinner and possibly find a spot for one of Border or S Waugh
 
Last edited:

pietersenrocks

U19 Vice-Captain
Sure, you say that. But what does husseyrocks think? :cool:
man,you wanna talk bout that again.....I can prove u all wrong.I was new here wen all dat happened.yeah,agree .. one member cant use 2 accounts,but 1 computer can use 2 accounts,both ov dem(me&my sis) were using them from da same computer and this website blamed me that i'm using two accounts.where's written that 1 computer cant use 2 accounts ??N' yeah .. why do u wanna keep irritating me for dis utter non-sense .. wen husseyrocks hasnt posted for a long time......anyways,bout husseyrocks........England Rules !!
 

Ikki

Hall of Fame Member
- Ponting for Harvey
- Waugh for Miller

And I can't believe the Don has 0 tonnes in 4 innings. I think he is averaging something like 42 an inning.
 

Matt79

Hall of Fame Member
man,you wanna talk bout that again.....I can prove u all wrong.I was new here wen all dat happened.yeah,agree .. one member cant use 2 accounts,but 1 computer can use 2 accounts,both ov dem(me&my sis) were using them from da same computer and this website blamed me that i'm using two accounts.where's written that 1 computer cant use 2 accounts ??N' yeah .. why do u wanna keep irritating me for dis utter non-sense .. wen husseyrocks hasnt posted for a long time......anyways,bout husseyrocks........England Rules !!
Just joking with you mate! :)
 

Matt79

Hall of Fame Member
- Ponting for Harvey
- Waugh for Miller

And I can't believe the Don has 0 tonnes in 4 innings. I think he is averaging something like 42 an inning.
Don will come good.

Re: Miller. He's been a disappointing with the bat, with 51 runs at 12.75. But he's taken 8 wickets at 20.3 so far - we need the extra fire power, and especially if we want to play O'Reilly at the SCG, we'll need him at the third seamer...
 

andyc

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
man,you wanna talk bout that again.....I can prove u all wrong.I was new here wen all dat happened.yeah,agree .. one member cant use 2 accounts,but 1 computer can use 2 accounts,both ov dem(me&my sis) were using them from da same computer and this website blamed me that i'm using two accounts.where's written that 1 computer cant use 2 accounts ??N' yeah .. why do u wanna keep irritating me for dis utter non-sense .. wen husseyrocks hasnt posted for a long time......anyways,bout husseyrocks........England Rules !!
lyk omg, 4 rlz?
 

The Sean

Cricketer Of The Year
Don will come good.

Re: Miller. He's been a disappointing with the bat, with 51 runs at 12.75. But he's taken 8 wickets at 20.3 so far - we need the extra fire power, and especially if we want to play O'Reilly at the SCG, we'll need him at the third seamer...
Agreed, he's bowled superbly and I'm sure will score runs when it matters at least once this series.

And the Don is due a couple of big scores now - wouldn't be surprised if he dominated the rest of the Series.

Australia's 4th innings batting is a real worry though, as is the Windies ability to turn around a 1st innings deficit so comfortably.
 

Slifer

International Captain
Must say Im surprised by the lack of centuries by the Don ( although i do expect him to get a few b4 the series is done). One has to remember however, that unlike his actual career the Don is facing an all time/worldclass bowling attack (the likes of which he hasnt ever faced b4). Also the first 2 wickets favored the Wi attack to a great degree (esp Perth). If i were Australia i wood definitely drop one of the pacemen and bring in a Grimmet or an O'reilley.

BTW are we going to have a return series in the Wi?
 

adharcric

International Coach
Slifer said:
BTW are we going to have a return series in the Wi?
Yes.

WI: Gibbs for the Melbourne Test? Holding would miss out if so, IMO. Give Greenidge another chance?

AUS: Ponting or Waugh should come in, surely. The second-innings batting has been pathetic thus far. O'Reilly for Lindwall?
 
Last edited:

Slifer

International Captain
I'd probably have Gibbs in for the Sydney test ( Im kinda wary of changing a winning combo). Would definitely make room for the great Steven Waugh (given his experience against the WI's attacks). I would replace Lindwall with O'reiley. Not sure if i wood do it for the MCG test but definitely at Sydney. An Attack of Miller, Mcgrath, lillee, warne and O'reilley on a turning Sydney track may be too much for the WI.
 

Top