SJS
Hall of Fame Member
I am agreeing (see earlier posts) that dropping him is right.I'm sorry, what? He HAS been dropped for this tour hasn't he?
I just happen to think he has been in the "not too good not too bad" category for the past year. So numbers wise, I don't a see a reason to drop him. However, if he is only ever going to play ODIs and if the selectors in their collective wisdom feel they can find someone who can do as good a job but is younger, there is no reason why he shouldn't be tried.
Here I was being sarcastic about his being a near permanent fixture in the Indian side with such an inconsistent performance.
Its a personal opinion, of course, as is anyone else's.