krkode
State Captain
Why would he walk if it was not out? That only adds to the supposed sillyness of the moveEyes_Only said:Nope...apparently it was not out!!

Why would he walk if it was not out? That only adds to the supposed sillyness of the moveEyes_Only said:Nope...apparently it was not out!!
]Eyes_Only said:Nope...apparently it was not out!!
Doesn't bode well if the forum's premier umpire gets things like this wrong!Top_Cat said:
Eyes: How on earth could you possibly say he wasn't out? Gilchrist walked pretty spontaneously so he must have known he hit it and in every possible replay, the edge was crystal-clear.
I wouldn't want her umpiring in a match I'm playing inTop_Cat said:Are we talking about the same Gilchrist dismissal? Because if we're talking about the one we think we are, Gilchrist was most definately OUT. Every replay of it showed a huge under-side edge onto his pad which ballooned up for the catch. He definately hit it.
Eyes: How on earth could you possibly say he wasn't out? Gilchrist walked pretty spontaneously so he must have known he hit it and in every possible replay, the edge was crystal-clear.
her?Rik said:I wouldn't want her umpiring in a match I'm playing in![]()
<quack>vishnureddy said:her?
Eyes is an umpire, and she is a woman too...vishnureddy said:her?
And if Eddie sticks his finger in the air then it's usually a prelude to a fightluckyeddie said:<quack>
Oh yes!!!
A few thoughts about umpires.
If David Shepherd sticks his finger in the air, the batsman's out.
If Venkat sticks his finger in the air, Yaju's just asked him if an aeroplane's flying over his head.
If Steve Bucknor sticks his finger in the air, it means the batsman was out 10 minutes ago.
If Billy Bowden sticks his finger in the air, it's a precursor to a song and dance.
If Eyes sticks her finger in the air, she's drying her nails.
Wasn't me, mate. I've just discovered that my account had been hacked.Rik said:And if Eddie sticks his finger in the air then it's usually a prelude to a fight![]()
I notice you didn't say anything about Simon Eddie...:Pluckyeddie said:<quack>
Oh yes!!!
A few thoughts about umpires.
If David Shepherd sticks his finger in the air, the batsman's out.
If Venkat sticks his finger in the air, Yaju's just asked him if an aeroplane's flying over his head.
If Steve Bucknor sticks his finger in the air, it means the batsman was out 10 minutes ago.
If Billy Bowden sticks his finger in the air, it's a precursor to a song and dance.
If Eyes sticks her finger in the air, she's drying her nails.
Interesting you should say that.....Eyes_Only said:Hey guys...
Thanks for the vote of confidence on my umpiring...
BTW Eddie...I don't put nail polish on my fingernails as I am unable to grow them as they break easily as I am alergic to milk and dairy products![]()
Take calcium tablets :PEyes_Only said:Hey guys...
Thanks for the vote of confidence on my umpiring...
BTW Eddie...I don't put nail polish on my fingernails as I am unable to grow them as they break easily as I am alergic to milk and dairy products![]()