the discussion on Ponting being left out caught my eye
haha, well anything could happen coz a team can only field 4 International players. Kol has McCullun, Gayle, D Hussey, Taibu, Gul and Asif, besides Ponting. Which 4 would you select to balance a side that has Ganguly, Agarkar, Kartik and Ishant
Now it has 3 Indian bowlers in Agarkar, Kartik & Ishant, so Kol will hv to play them, which means one of Gul and Akthar will get a look in [depending upon who is fit], with the 5th bowling option shared by Gayle and Ganguly [unless Kol has a quality all-rounder from the local quota]. with Gayle coming in as an all-rounder and McCullun as the WK the 4th spot goes to Ponting, I guess. btw, i read reports that D Hussey is contracted to play County cricket so may not be available. While Ponting may go to Pak and that implies that Gul and Akthar will not be there too. So Taibu probably has more chances of playing in the X1
A team appears different when you consider the combinations and availability of key players. Kol may appear strong on paper but IMO it's not amongst the top 3 teams. And you can't bank on Ganguly and Agarkar, esp in 20-20
Same goes for B'lore. Although, it has a nice bowling attack, the batting does not look good enough to score consistently at 8 an over. Let's look at B'lore's line up
Kallis, Boucher, White, Steyn, Bracken, & C'paul ---> 4 of them will be in the playing X1 with Dravid, Jaffar, Kumble & Zak
so let's make B'lore's X1 ----> Dravid, Jaffar, Kumble & Zak. throw in the wk Boucher and Kallis. Now it will probably pick two from Steyn, Bracken and White. White, if Blore needs someone with all-rounder's abilities which means one from Bracken and Steyn.
Doesn't look like a gr8 team to me. Probably the weakest, along with Jaipur!!!
This is how I would describe the teams
- Hybad ----> all round solidity w/ good openers, middle order and some good bowlers
- Mohali ----> solid middle order with a balanced bowling attack
- Mumbai ----> explosive players with experience
- Delhi ----> a nice mix of players, with some being from the two 20-20 WC finalists
- Kolkatta ----> some good names in the squad
- Banglore -----> Good bowling unit
- Jaipur ----> Warne!!!!
- Chennai ----> some solid international players but weak support players [unfortunately for it, only 4 int players can play]
This is how i would rank the sides
Top ----> Hybad & Mohali [in no paricular order]
Middle ----> Mumbai, Delhi, Chennai & Kolkatta [in no particular order]
Bottom ----> Banglore and Jaipur [in no particular order]
cheers