• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Warne vs Gavaskar

Warne vs Gavaskar


  • Total voters
    23

DrWolverine

International 12th Man
That's not decisive. Post the rankings of them as a batsman and a bowler.
Post WW

Sachin. Smith. Sobers. Viv. Lara.
Only batsmen who are better than Sunny(imo)
The rest are debatable.

Marshall. Hadlee. McGrath. Ambrose. Steyn. Imran. Donald. Garner.
I am picking all of them over Warne.
 

sayon basak

International Captain

Skip to 7:31


Don't think Gavaskar should have answered exactly in that manner, but why would someone ask that kind of question in a tribute to Warne? (specially when you pretty much know what he's gonna answer. Tbh, Gavaskar was just being honest, I'll give it to him)
 

Johan

International Regular
Gavaskar probably wanted Shane to be #2 among spinners because Gavaskar alongside Hammond is the premier #2 in cricketting history.
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
Post WW

Sachin. Smith. Sobers. Viv. Lara.
Only batsmen who are better than Sunny(imo)
The rest are debatable.

Marshall. Hadlee. McGrath. Ambrose. Steyn. Imran. Donald. Garner.
I am picking all of them over Warne.
I will say all but Sachin are debatable, though I will place Gavaskar behind all
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year

Skip to 7:31


Don't think Gavaskar should have answered exactly in that manner, but why would someone ask that kind of question in a tribute to Warne? (specially when you pretty much know what he's gonna answer. Tbh, Gavaskar was just being honest, I'll give it to him)
I think the reporter certainly expected "Yes" to be the answer. It certainly was a very awkward tangent given Warne just passed away, should had just said something like "I will probably place a few ahead" or something really. But well, I won't make a fuss over it really, like I will do of his comments on David Hookes' death.
 

OverratedSanity

Request Your Custom Title Now!
It certainly was a very awkward tangent given Warne just passed away, should had just said something like "I will probably place a few ahead" or something really.
This is very easy to do btw.

Not surprised robots like Pews think Gavaskar's response was fine tbh.
 

kyear2

International Coach
Over careers, I don't think there's much to separate Viv and Sunny. That pretty much covers it. After Don, it's Hobbs and Tendulkar; then Sobers, Lara, Smith, Hutton, Viv and Sunny.
Why?

Besides you saying so of course?

What puts Sunny into that group of the greatest batsmen ever?

Anecdotally? Peer rating? All time team selections? Being the best batsman batsman in the world over a prolonged period, or at all in this case?

What is the argument for Sunny being the best batsman ever bar Bradman.

And while you're at it, what makes Sachin better than the others? What makes him better than Viv, Sobers or Smith? Everyone else believes that it's a contest among equals.

Because at this point your only argument seems to be that they're from your fav country.
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
Why?

Besides you saying so of course?

What puts Sunny into that group of the greatest batsmen ever?

Anecdotally? Peer rating? All time team selections? Being the best batsman batsman in the world over a prolonged period, or at all in this case?

What is the argument for Sunny being the best batsman ever bar Bradman.

And while you're at it, what makes Sachin better than the others? What makes him better than Viv, Sobers or Smith? Everyone else believes that it's a contest among equals.

Because at this point your only argument seems to be that they're from your fav country.
Output. Peer ratings and All Time selections are extremely shitty metrics and being the best batsman over a period is arguably for many. Arguably Lara was never, as was Sobers'. Will you say they don't have a shot as well?? Ofcourse you wouldn't.
Sachin's 23 years long near perfect record. That's what separates Sachin from Viv, Smith and Sobers.
You are literally the last person who should bring in favour country argument z after stating Sobers to be Don's equal.
 

Top