-
Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.
Un-Even Trading Yes or No?
- Thread starter Cloete
- Start date
marc71178
Eyes not spreadsheets
If you want to make suggestions that's fine, but there's a way to making suggestions, and starting polls is not the way.
If you have ideas then U2U a member of the board and ask them to discuss it - however this particular rule would be unlikely to change because it's already been discussed at length when the equal trades was brought in.
If you have ideas then U2U a member of the board and ask them to discuss it - however this particular rule would be unlikely to change because it's already been discussed at length when the equal trades was brought in.
But y not polling.We can get to see the majority.If the point is discussed only by 6 board members then there is only 6 views and by polling we get 30 views.Decision should be made by the board but by taking everyones view in account.After the result of the poll the board members can decide which option is good taking in account the general view also.
Yeah, but it's still GB's baby and what he decides goes. If we don't like the way he wants to run it, we have the choice not to participate. Whilst I fully agree that it's good to discuss new ideas, this one has been flogged to death on several occasions and GB has made his position clear. Let's have the good grace to accept his decision.
age_master
Hall of Fame Member
while i ageree and respect that i want to say that i really do think that since people have serious opinions we should have a discussion about it, as long as tempers stay calm etc
nibbs
International Captain
I think all members of WCC should be aloud to vote in a new board at the start of next season, with the exception of GB, and Rich who deservedly hold a place. As for all the other positions they should be for us, the members, to decide, just like the do in Fifa or other sports bodies!
Who here agrees?
Who here agrees?
age_master
Hall of Fame Member
i think it should be 3 permanant members and 1 voted in, if a vote were to take place GB would have the final say if it were deadlocked - and on the 3 permanant members - GB, Rich and Buggs
Rik
Cricketer Of The Year
Sheesh this is getting like Lord Of The Flies!!! :rolleyes:
I think there should be a board but also since we all take part in this league we should all have a say in some of the issues. I for one do not want unequal trading as GB has made it so that each side must have 16 players, no more, no less. Allow people to trade multiple players for one player takes away the balance.
I think a better idea would be thinking about the single transfer of players: Making it so that you sign who you want or you pick them up in the draft later, as you can't sign loads of other players you don't want then trade them on for someone else you do want.
That would be a better discussion.
I think there should be a board but also since we all take part in this league we should all have a say in some of the issues. I for one do not want unequal trading as GB has made it so that each side must have 16 players, no more, no less. Allow people to trade multiple players for one player takes away the balance.
I think a better idea would be thinking about the single transfer of players: Making it so that you sign who you want or you pick them up in the draft later, as you can't sign loads of other players you don't want then trade them on for someone else you do want.
That would be a better discussion.
age_master
Hall of Fame Member
why not, i see no problem with that, also it was voted on and people tended to agree with this viewpoint
How does the balance goes.U have to retain 10 in the end before the draft.So U can trade 3 of 1 or 2 for 1.And in the end decide on which 10 u want to retain before the DP and all others are gone in the Draft.By doing this if u give three above avg players to a team which has just a single good player and no one else.So the team become strong by getting 3 players who are not as good as the one traded but can balance the week side.Rik said:
Mr Mxyzptlk
Request Your Custom Title Now!
I fully agree with the voting in of Board Members.
Actually last season we had unequal trading and it didnt cause that much problem, the problem was when it came to draft pick. As long as every team ends up with 10 players before the draft uneven trading should be allowed.Rik said:
As for the board, im not a member so i dont know what goes on, but i still picture WCC to be GB's so he makes the ultimate decision with the assistance of board members. So i dont see if being on the board will make any difference, like if u were to tell GB a reasonable suggestion im sure he would consider it.