Top Five Cricketers from each country

[mr_mister]

And Headley is the only bloke who's 100s to test ratio was close to Bradman

Maybe he really is the undisputed number 2

 

[Malcolm]

 

[Malcolm]

So many surprising poll results

Hayden > Bevan
Waugh jr > Jones
Warnie > Mcgrath, Chappell

 

[h_hurricane]

There is no way on god's green earth would Warne make it in ODIs ahead of Mcgrath.

 

[mr_mister]

I mean casuals don't have the same love affair for Dean Jones as an ODI great as CW

And they would also probably assume Warne to be the GOAT regardless of format

 

[ankitj]

So many surprising poll results

Hayden > Bevan
Waugh jr > Jones
Warnie > Mcgrath, Chappell

And Lee > Watson

 

[bagapath]

Border absolutely is a CW thing. Shame on you.

Absolutely. The true AB

 

[Pap Finn Keighl]

Gilly
McGrath
Ponting
Bevan
Jones
Symonds
Watson
M.Waugh
Lillee
Chappell
Lee
Warne

 

[stephen]

Just goes to show the people voting on this are probably mostly people who haven't watched much cricket from the 80s/90s.

Jones vs Waugh is pretty close. Jones probably better but Waugh had an excellent career. But the killer is that Jones played so long ago you basically need to be at least mid 30s, if not in your 40s to remember him batting.

Hayden vs Bevan result was a sad joke. Hayden was awesome but was nowhere near Bevan in ODIs. Bevan criminally underrated. I bet Red Hill voted like 100 times in that poll.

Brett Lee making the final 4 ahead of McGrath is simply absurd.

It's pretty clear the final will be between Ponting and Warne, which is ok, but Australia's best ODI bat (Bevan) and ODI bowler (McGrath) were both knocked out earlier.

 

[trundler]

McGrath not making the final makes the whole thing a joke. Warne's reputation is built around his world cup performances but McGrath was still the greatest WC bowler, bar none.

 

[OverratedSanity]

Bevan knocked out in round 1 is pretty funny

 

[trundler]

Filthy casuals

 

[Borges]

Filthy ignorant Indians, I'm sure. Why are these guys allowed to vote at all?

 

[trundler]

Filthy ignorant Indians, I'm sure. Why are these guys allowed to vote at all?

As evidenced by the exit polls

 

[Malcolm]

Brett Lee is an all-time great ODI bowler,
handy lower order batsman and a brilliant fielder.
I don't think Lee making it to the final 4 is absurd.

 

[Pap Finn Keighl]

Just goes to show the people voting on this are probably mostly people who haven't watched much cricket from the 80s/90s.

Jones vs Waugh is pretty close. Jones probably better but Waugh had an excellent career. But the killer is that Jones played so long ago you basically need to be at least mid 30s, if not in your 40s to remember him batting.

Hayden vs Bevan result was a sad joke. Hayden was awesome but was nowhere near Bevan in ODIs. Bevan criminally underrated. I bet Red Hill voted like 100 times in that poll.

Brett Lee making the final 4 ahead of McGrath is simply absurd.

It's pretty clear the final will be between Ponting and Warne, which is ok, but Australia's best ODI bat (Bevan) and ODI bowler (McGrath) were both knocked out earlier.

Gilly better than all

 

[vcs]

Strange. You'd expect those results to show up on a Facebook or Cricinfo poll rather than on here.

 

[mr_mister]

I saw that on FB before I saw it here

 

[Bolo]

I mean casuals don't have the same love affair for Dean Jones as an ODI great as CW

And they would also probably assume Warne to be the GOAT regardless of format

The general casual opinion would probably have Warne at 2nd in both formats. Nothing wrong with this I think. He had a full length odi career and didn't chuck. CW is a bit harsh on him in odis, particularly considering the lack of competition.

 

[trundler]

Murali> Saqlain >> Warne> the rest.