The ATG Teams General arguing/discussing thread

[ataraxia]

Just looks slightly weaker than the normal:

Fredericks
Haynes
Worrell* - 5
Weekes
Lloyd/Kanhai
Walcott +
Whatever
Down
Over
Here

Certainly makes the third XI look weaker without Kanhai/Lloyd. Agree that it isn't weak at all, but it just seems wrong with Worrell opening to me. Eh.

 

[bagapath]

In my books three Windies team with one obligatory spinner look like...


greenidge
hunte
richards
lara
headley
sobers *
dujon +
marshall
holding
ambrose
gibbs

haynes
fredericks
worrell *
weekes
walcott
chanderpaul
murray +
roberts
garner
ramadin
walsh

gayle
stollmeyer
richardson
kanhai
kallicharan
lloyd *
jacobs +
hall
croft
bishop
valentine

 

[ataraxia]

Learie Constantine a shot.

 

[ataraxia]

Auckland:
MH Richardson
HG Vivian
JF Reid
MD Crowe
GP Howarth
C de Grandhomme
AC Parore +
?
LH Ferguson
J Cowie
HJ Howarth

Canterbury:
TWM Latham
GT Dowling
SP Fleming
NJ Astle
HM Nicholls
CD McMillan
RJ Hadlee
LK Germon +
BR Taylor
TB Burtt
SE Bond


Wellington:
CS Dempster
BA Edgar
BW Sinclair
MP Donnelly
JR Reid
JV Coney
KC James +
?
?
TL Pritchard
EJ Chatfield

More to come very soon.

 

[ataraxia]

Central Districts:
MS Sinclair
AH Jones
BE Congdon
LRPL Taylor
JD Ryder
JDP Oram
IDS Smith +
?
RO Collinge
?
?

Northern Districts:
JG Wright
BA Young
KS Williamson
HJH Marshall
BJ Watling +
SP Styris
CL Cairns
DL Vettori
SB Doull
TG Southee
TA Boult

Otago:
GM Turner
HD Rutherford
B Sutcliffe
RC Blunt
BB McCullum
KR Rutherford
WK Lees +
BL Cairns
JG Bracewell
N Wagner
FJ Cameron

All are the domestic districts that they played for first. Couldn't be that bothered to finish out some of the bowling units. Really annoyed that Hamish Rutherford is the best candidate for that last spot I could think of.

 

[Slifer]

In my books three Windies team with one obligatory spinner look like...


greenidge
hunte
richards
lara
headley
sobers *
dujon +
marshall
holding
ambrose
gibbs

haynes
fredericks
worrell *
weekes
walcott
chanderpaul
murray +
roberts
garner
ramadin
walsh

gayle
stollmeyer
richardson
kanhai
kallicharan
lloyd *
jacobs +
hall
croft
bishop
valentine

4th XI

Rae
Samuels (Robert)
Rowe
Adams
Butcher
Nurse
Alexander+*
Harper
Griffith
Roach
Petterson

Wow really scraping the bottom of the barrel here

 

[jimmy101]

Auckland:
MH Richardson
HG Vivian
JF Reid
MD Crowe
GP Howarth
C de Grandhomme
AC Parore +
?
LH Ferguson
J Cowie
HJ Howarth

Canterbury:
TWM Latham
GT Dowling
SP Fleming
NJ Astle
HM Nicholls
CD McMillan
RJ Hadlee
LK Germon +
BR Taylor
TB Burtt
SE Bond


Wellington:
CS Dempster
BA Edgar
BW Sinclair
MP Donnelly
JR Reid
JV Coney
KC James +
?
?
TL Pritchard
EJ Chatfield

Central Districts:
MS Sinclair
AH Jones
BE Congdon
LRPL Taylor
JD Ryder
JDP Oram
IDS Smith +
?
RO Collinge
?
?

Northern Districts:
JG Wright
BA Young
KS Williamson
HJH Marshall
BJ Watling +
SP Styris
CL Cairns
DL Vettori
SB Doull
TG Southee
TA Boult

Otago:
GM Turner
HD Rutherford
B Sutcliffe
RC Blunt
BB McCullum
KR Rutherford
WK Lees +
BL Cairns
JG Bracewell
N Wagner
FJ Cameron

All are the domestic districts that they played for first. Couldn't be that bothered to finish out some of the bowling units. Really annoyed that Hamish Rutherford is the best candidate for that last spot I could think of.

Martin Snedden is a solid candidate to round out that Auckland side. Simon Doull & Jeet Patel for Wellington. As for Central Districts, Adam Milne, Michael Mason & Doug Bracewell are a few Centrals players that could make up their XI.

 

[OverratedSanity]

4th XI

Rae
Samuels (Robert)
Rowe
Adams
Butcher
Nurse
Alexander+*
Harper
Griffith
Roach
Petterson

Wow really scraping the bottom of the barrel here

Sarwan ahead of adams imo

 

[Red]

New South Wales

Arthur Morris
Sid Barnes
Don Bradman
Stan McCabe/Neil Harvey
Victor Trumper
Steve Waugh/Monty Noble
Adam Gilchrist +
Ray Lindwall
Allan Davidson
Bill OReilly
Glenn McGrath

Might be stretching a bit having Bradman, Harvey and Gilchrist, but they played for NSW.

 

[Red]

Victoria

Woodfull
Lawry
Ponsford
Harvey
Hassett
Jones
Miller
Armstrong
Warne
Berry +
Hughes

 

[ankitj]

Northern Hemisphere:

Hobbs, Gavaskar, Richards, Tendulkar, Lara, Sobers, Knott +, Imran *, Marshall, Muralidharan, Barnes

Southern hemisphere:

Richards, Mitchell, Bradman *, Pollock, Smith, Kallis, Gilchrist +, Hadlee, Warne, Steyn, McGrath

Southerners win because Bradman.

 

[ankitj]

If Barnes is not considered a true fast bowler, can be easily replaced by Ambrose.

 

[ataraxia]

Martin Snedden is a solid candidate to round out that Auckland side. Simon Doull & Jeet Patel for Wellington. As for Central Districts, Adam Milne, Michael Mason & Doug Bracewell are a few Centrals players that could make up their XI.

Doull's already in the ND side. Good ideas, tbh I kind of got bored wafting through the bowlers.

 

[ataraxia]

New South Wales

Arthur Morris
Sid Barnes
Don Bradman
Stan McCabe/Neil Harvey
Victor Trumper
Steve Waugh/Monty Noble
Adam Gilchrist +
Ray Lindwall
Allan Davidson
Bill OReilly
Glenn McGrath

Might be stretching a bit having Bradman, Harvey and Gilchrist, but they played for NSW.

Bob Simpson?

 

[ankitj]

2nd XIs

Northern Hemisphere:

Hutton, Sutcliffe, Hammond, Sangakkara *, Kohli, Botham, Ames +, Akram, Ambrose, Trueman, Laker

Southern hemisphere:

G Smith, Hayden, Ponting *, Chappell, Border, Miller, Flower +, S Pollock, Lillee, Donald, O'Reilly

 

[Red]

Bob Simpson?

Forgot him. Definitely a contender.

 

[ataraxia]

Also Trumper if you are willing to go back that far. NSW would beat most country's teams in neutral conditions.

 

[jimmy101]

You'd think Smith would just about walk into the NSW side. Bradman belongs with SA, so I'd personally throw in Smith for Braddles.

 

[Red]

Also Trumper if you are willing to go back that far. NSW would beat most country's teams in neutral conditions.

Trumper's at 5 in my NSW team.

 

[Red]

You'd think Smith would just about walk into the NSW side. Bradman belongs with SA, so I'd personally throw in Smith for Braddles.

Yeh I know. But he played for NSW and was born and raised there. NSW XI is ridiculous.