Strongest Batting combination

[capt_Luffy]

Wrong comparison. Amla should be compared to Dravid and Laxman should be compared to Gilchrist because of their batting position

So Hayden Sehwag Smith
Ponting Dravid Amla
Steve Sachin Kallis
Gilly Laxman Devilliers

And ofcourse, Sachin to Hayden
@shortpitched713

 

[shortpitched713]

Wrong comparison. Amla should be compared to Dravid and Laxman should be compared to Gilchrist because of their batting position

I only compared openers by position, then the rest of the middle order in order of their quality. It highlights the potential difference in quality a bit better as compared to some big mismatches like DeVilliers/Gilchrist vs Laxman or Ponting/Dravid vs Amla.

 

[shortpitched713]

And ofcourse, Sachin to Hayden
@shortpitched713

Obviously!

 

[kyear2]

Here is my rating

Smith > Sehwag> Hayden
Ponting > Dravid > Amla
Sachin >Kallis > Steve Waugh
Devilliers > Laxman > Gilchrist

SA = 1+1+2+3 = 7
IND = 2+2+1+2 = 7
AUS = 3+1+3+3 =10

So IND = SA > AUS

Smith > Hayden > Sehwag
Ponting > Dravid > Amla
Sachin > Kallis > Waugh
deVilliers > Gilchrist > Laxman

SA - 7
Aus - 8
Ind - 9

 

[Sunil1z]

Smith > Hayden > Sehwag
Ponting > Dravid > Amla
Sachin > Kallis > Waugh
deVilliers > Gilchrist > Laxman

SA - 7
Aus - 8
Ind - 9

Laxman is better batsman than Gilly . Won’t argue about others .

 

[kyear2]

Laxman is better batsman than Gilly . Won’t argue about others .

Wouldn't argue either, just think Gilly's impact was possibly greater. Even if less skilled.