Insane is right!!! It doesn't really matter, does it, whether some false decisions were given or not. If Langer had gone cheaply, who's to say that Ponting wouldn't have scored a ton? Or Waugh? Or Love? Or Gilchrist?...Now, that's not being optimistic, it's merely being realistic.Neil Pickup said:Hey... I was just being insanely optimistic
I definitely think Dawson got one of the openers yesterday (can't remember who) caught behind but it wasn't given.
If Foster is that bad, why are England persisting with him(Is he from Surrey or something?)? Why don't they try out Read instead?marc71178 said:Mind you I also heard he didn't walk because he didn't believe that Foster had held onto one! [/B]
For this game it's because he was part of the original squad and Read wasn't.anilramavarma said:If Foster is that bad, why are England persisting with him(Is he from Surrey or something?)? Why don't they try out Read instead?
Averages do not tell the whole story - he has bowled well despite the figures he's achieved.Rik said:It seems they have the same idea about Dawson...in The Cricketer there was a bit about Nasser saying how impressed he was with Dawson during the tour...before the Test his FC Tour Bowling Average was 78...3 Wickets in 3 Games...:OWOW:O...or not as the case may be
Yes but Wickets matter. He's just never really threatened. I'm aggressively minded as a Cricketer but having to watch this guy serving up delivery after delivery for the Aussies to smash back! It would be ok if he kept it tight, but he hasn't even done that!marc71178 said:Averages do not tell the whole story - he has bowled well despite the figures he's achieved.
Did I ever say that any of the other bowlers had done anything of note? Caddick looks worse than useless and Harmison needs to start using that pace. Dawson is just another mediocre bowler in a poor bowling attack. Tudor has lost everything that ever made him a good bowler and Hoggard can't do much unless the ball swings. The only bowlers so far with credit are Jones and Giles who I had critisised recently due to not taking many Wickets in the summer. If there is a weakness with the Aussies then it's spin, but the spinner needs to be a good one.marc71178 said:No, all the averages will be that high because of the number of runs conceded.