Some More Team Trades

[subshakerz]

Do they trade?

2000s Aus trade Ponting for Miller?

2010s Ind trade Jadeja for Kirsten?

70s/80s England trade Botham for Andy Flower?

90s WI trade Ambrose for Warne?

2000s SA trade Smith for Murali?

 

[Johan]

Probably not?

No

No

Maybe

Yes.

 

[DrWolverine]

Do they trade?

2000s Aus trade Ponting for Miller? No

2010s Ind trade Jadeja for Kirsten? No

70s/80s England trade Botham for Andy Flower? No

90s WI trade Ambrose for Warne? No

2000s SA trade Smith for Murali? Yes

 

[Gob]

Do they trade?

2000s Aus trade Ponting for Miller?

2010s Ind trade Jadeja for Kirsten?

70s/80s England trade Botham for Andy Flower?

90s WI trade Ambrose for Warne?

2000s SA trade Smith for Murali?

They are all solid nos but this one in particular is awful

 

[capt_Luffy]

Yes

Wtf No

No, Nope

Probs Yes

Defo Yes

 

[Thala_0710]

No
No
No
Yes
Yes

 

[subshakerz]

They are all solid nos but this one in particular is awful

My apologies. I thought since there isn't any standout Eng keeper in the 80s his role as that and ATVG bat gain more value.

 

[sayon basak]

Do they trade?

No

 

[subshakerz]

No

Ambrose for Warne even?

 

[sayon basak]

Ambrose for Warne even?

No.

Only the last one they should.

 

[vidiq]

Do they trade?

2000s Aus trade Ponting for Miller?

2010s Ind trade Jadeja for Kirsten?

70s/80s England trade Botham for Andy Flower?

90s WI trade Ambrose for Warne?

2000s SA trade Smith for Murali?

No
Yes (kuldeep, Axar are equally dengerous)
No
Yes
Yes

 

[subshakerz]

Wtf No

Why is Jadeja so important? They can replace him as spinner but they really need an all round quality opening bat.

 

[Migara]

Do they trade?

2000s Aus trade Ponting for Miller?

2010s Ind trade Jadeja for Kirsten?

70s/80s England trade Botham for Andy Flower?

90s WI trade Ambrose for Warne?

2000s SA trade Smith for Murali?

Yes. Miller was the type of player they were lacking. Ponting could have been replaced by Law, Hodge or Dussey who would have done good.
No. Kirsten is just not an elite opener. May be a case for Hashim Amla.
Difficult decision. May be Botham.
They will kill for it.
They will kill for it. Last two instances, that is what they lacked. Even the best ever spinners these sides ever had are couple of rungs below these two.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Why is Jadeja so important? They can replace him as spinner but they really need an all round quality opening bat.

Kirsten isn't elite enough and Jadeja nearly as replaceable as you might think

 

[subshakerz]

Kirsten isn't elite enough and Jadeja nearly as replaceable as you might think

Axar and Kuldeep cover him more or less as spinner. Axar also bats well at home.

Whereas Indias batting faced trouble in SA, Eng and NZ and needs shoring up.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Axar and Kuldeep cover him more or less as spinner. Axar also bats well at home.

Whereas Indias batting faced trouble in SA, Eng and NZ and needs shoring up.

meh. I ain't trading an AR like Jadeja for Kirsten, tho I am a Kirsten fan. Axar isn't Jadeja.