• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Player Ratings Thread

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
He does seem a bit toothless with the ball sometimes, but it's still early days and in these conditions I'd probably have him ahead of the spin bowling allrounder you guys tend to always play. If he can add a bit more sw ing, he'd be fine.

He's probably been your best bat so far in the tournament so that should justify his selection.
I mean, I would play him over Rohit but he is really not the guy you wanna play at 8. The way I see it, NKR fights with Washy and Jaddu for the #7 slot and we should play Ash or Harshit Rana at 8. Ideally -

Rahul
Jaiswal
Gill
Virat
Pant (wk)
NKR
Jaddu
Ash
3 seamers
 

Himannv

Hall of Fame Member
I mean, I would play him over Rohit but he is really not the guy you wanna play at 8. The way I see it, NKR fights with Washy and Jaddu for the #7 slot and we should play Ash or Harshit Rana at 8. Ideally -

Rahul
Jaiswal
Gill
Virat
Pant (wk)
NKR
Jaddu
Ash
3 seamers
Not enough allrounders in your team.
 

morgieb

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Khawaja 3 - got a decent start first innings which enabled the middle order to dominate, but still doesn't look very comfortable and the knives are starting to come out.
McSweeney 2 - no runs but at least ate up time when an collapse could've caused trouble.
Labuschagne 2 - awful shot after doing the hard work. He seems to be too easy to frustrate right now.
Smith 8 - it wasn't pretty (at least the first 50 runs weren't), but it was an extremely important ton when Australia (and him) really needed it. And yet, might've cost Australia the game with that drop....
Head 10 - machine. Is keeping Australia's batting afloat single-handedly. What was most impressive about this knock is that it was extremely controlled, his only drop happening when he was well past 100. MOTS so far, along with Bumrah.
Marsh 1 - he shouldn't be playing. If he's selected for the MCG it's suicide.
Carey 7 - very good 70-odd to keep the momentum going after a bit of a mini-collapse and give Australia a big enough score to try to push for victory. Kept well too, including taking a screamer.
Cummins 8 - faltered with the last wicket partnership, but before that was superb. Also put on a nice partnership with Carey. It's safe to say the slump he had for a few Tests was just that and he's bowling as solidly as ever.
Starc 7 - two wickets in his first two overs, then a bit quiet after that though still bowled reasonably well and the lack of bowling options meant that Australia couldn't use him in the best way possible. Decent cameo with the bat.
Lyon 4 - not great. Didn't bowl terribly but wasn't particularly penetrative and needed a freak catch for his one wicket. With Hazlewood down he had to step up for Australia to win the Test, and him not doing so doomed the game to a draw.
Hazlewood 5 - bowled well before breaking down. Given the circumstances his selection will bring up a lot of question marks. I don't know whether the calf strain was linked to the side strain or not, but it does feel awfully coincidential.

Jaiswal 1 - 4 and out. Seems after the "bowl faster" sledge Starc has had the wood on him massively.
Rahul 7 - has looked the most comfortable of the Top 6. Did get dropped early-ish in his knock but made the most of his luck and was perhaps unlucky to get out to such a good catch. Unlike the rest of the Indian batting lineup has batted with a plan and other than gloving a few short balls he's been excellent so far.
Gill 1 - what on earth was that shot so early when you were already one down.
Kohli 1 - it looks llike the hundred at Perth was a fluke. It's just very easy to work him over right now and the end feels like it's coming.
Pant 2 - it's clear he's not moving as well as he used for (for admittedly understandable reasons) and it's having a bit of an impact on his batting. He just doesn't feel as comfortable in the middle as he once did. Wasn't terrible with the gloves, I suppose.
Sharma 1 - looks in awful touch. While you can argue he's batting out of position, he still looks out of sorts and if it wasn't for the captaincy he'd be out of the side quick smart.
Jadeja 7 - very good innings when India needed it. However, his bowling was pretty ineffective and was battered significantly by Head.
Reddy 5 - not as good as the first two Tests with the bat, but did put on a good partnership with Jadeja when failure might lead to Australia rolling the rest of the batting lineup quickly and putting them under pressure for the rest of the Test. Did take a wicket but a higher workload did expose the fact that his bowling at least right now probably isn't good enough for Test cricket.
Siraj 4 - hot and cold. Did bowl some good balls, but also threw up a heap of short crap that went the journey. At least he didn't completely lose his head, I guess.
Bumrah 9 - he's just very good isn't he? Has carried India all series. If India get a positive result from the series, it's up there with one of the greatest series of all-time. Injuries and weird scheduling has hurt his longevity somewhat, but we're talking one of the greatest bowlers of all-time at this point.
Deep 6 - a bit unlucky with the ball in the first innings, though I do feel like he went down the Hilfy path a bit too much in that he bowled in pretty areas but perhaps didn't bowl a wicket-taking line and length often enough. That said, his innings (and partnership with Bumrah) turned out to be really important in saving the Test. Why was he batting below Siraj exactly?
 
Last edited:

Gnske

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Khawaja 0 - He's done
McSweeney 1 - For trying
Labuschagne 0.5 - Miserable
Smith 8 - No one's ever really gone
Head 10 - God among men
Marsh 0 - You missing Shane "No crust on my penis" Watson? me too
Carey 6 - Very serviceable
Cummins 5 - Idiot captaincy but his bowling is warming up
Starc 0 - Actually listened to his captain.
Lyon 2 - Got carted
Hazlewood 10 - Superb work for a broken man
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
You are right.

Revised XI -

Jaiswal
Rahul
Washy
NKR
Axar
Jurel (wk)
Jaddu
Ash
Akashdeep
Bumrah (c)
Siraj


I am pretty sure they will make a lot more runs per innings than our current 11.
Not a HB team to core..... Imo:

Jaiswal
Rahul
Washy
NKR
Pant+
Jadeja
Ashwin
Kuldeep
Bishnoi
Bumrah
Khaleel

Right arm fast, left arm fast, be right arm medium, off spin, left arm spin, leg spin, chinaman..... Everything is covered now.
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
India
Jaiswal - 2:
Scored 4 runs and got out to Starc poorly, and 4* in the 2nd.
Rahul - 9: Great innings under pressure when everyone shitted pants, without which we would had lost. Was dropped once, but got out to a howler as well. He really is a huge POA.
Gill - 1.5: Poor choice of short and gone for cheap again....
Kohli - 1.5: Sometimes it feels like a script..... **** you Kohli
Pant - 2: Actually got out to a decent delivery.... Kept alright.
Rohit - 0.5: Some of the worst captaincy I have ever witnessed. From field placement to bowler rotation to sending Siraj at 9, everything a child's kiss...... **** you Rohit
Reddy - 4.5: Not as good as the previous matches, but a good partnership with Jadeja and bowled..... Serviceable.
Jadeja - 6.5: Batting was more like 9.5; marking him negatively for bowling such filth
Akash Deep - 6.5: Unlucky with the ball in the 1st innings, did reasonable in the 2nd; very valuable 30 runs though, really valuable.
Mohammad Siraj - 4.5: Should has bowled better in the 1st innings, did good in the 2nd. But don't you ****ing dare to try to bat above 11.
Jasprit Bumrah - 10: Pretty much took every important wicket in the 1st innings, got the break throughs in the 2nd and would had gotten his 10 fer had the cheating Aussies not cowered up and declared to prevent that. Also extremely important partnership with Akash Deep for the last wicket, saving the follow on. Take my firstborn Bumrah.


Australia:
McSweeney - 3: Saw off the new ball relatively in the 1st innings
Khawaja - 3.5:
Same as McSweeney really, though scored more
Labuschagne - 2: Again, made sure the ball got old; but a really pathetic way to go
Smith - 8.5: Great, now Smith is back scoring runs again.....
Head - 10: The hate I have for this man is not palpable by mere words.
Marsh - 1: Batted really awful and can't be called up to bowl even when you are down to 3 bowlers
Carey - 7.5: Again providing valuable late order runs; and nudging a few a in the 2nd innings as well. Also grabbed a howler.
Cummins - 7.5: Bowled well and a good knock among ruins in the 2nd innings. Kinda bad captaincy though
Starc - 7: Good start with the ball, but nothing much really.
Hazlewood - 8.5: Bowled brilliantly while fit
Lyon - 4: was serviceable, ig
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
Not a HB team to core..... Imo:

Jaiswal
Rahul
Washy
NKR
Pant+
Jadeja
Ashwin
Kuldeep
Bishnoi
Bumrah
Khaleel

Right arm fast, left arm fast, be right arm medium, off spin, left arm spin, leg spin, chinaman..... Everything is covered now.
My India side in Real Cricket 24 goes -

Rohit (c)
Jaiswal
Washy
Virat
Pant (wk)
Hardik
Jaddu
Ashwin
Unadkat
Bhuvi
Bumrah

:)
 

Top