SirBloody Idiot
Cricketer Of The Year
Actually, probabaly Voges would be the best bet of those in England.
Recently broke his finger. Unlikely to play out the rest of the season with Glamorgan, as he was only a temporary stand in I believe for Gibbs. I believe he will continue playing club cricket and 2nd XI cricket for Glamorgan.God will hate me for this, but Mark Cosgrove is averaging 70+. Admittedly it is Divi 2, but don't Glamorgan play at Cardiff...?
Might need to dust off Warwick Armstrong's baggy green. I'm sure it is resting in a museum somewhere.Ahh **** that's right.
Cosgrove for the Baggy Green (do they have it in his size?)
Voges was in Townsville last weekend for Australia A vs Pakistan A. He top scored with 80-odd.
Actually he didn't top score Krejza got 100.
Get Well Soon Watto!Actually, probabaly Voges would be the best bet of those in England.
I think sending him home would be too harsh, but given his history of injuries, atleast a shadow player should be send as back-up, it can be Hodge or David Hussey (who is currently playing for Notts in England).He should be sent home, and another batsman sent over there to replace him, imo.
Aren't the tests back-to-back? If so, he's realistically out of the first two tests, isn't he? There's no opportunity for him to present a case for selectionthen until the third test FFS.
Geez, Voges or Dussey?Get Well Soon Watto!
Dussey has done NOTHING to inspire any confidence in his ability to step up a class irrespective of how many runs he has scored in English CCDavid Hussey has a magnificent domestic record, and especially in England. There's no reason why he shouldn't be next in line. Hodge would obviously be the other one. The others however, not so much.
Errr, tough one. It's debateable whether being crap at cricket is classed as a mental affliction or not, but I don't think it's generally what people refer to when they use the word.Yes of course, but is not making a mistake a mental error?
The way I see it you can get out two different ways in cricket. Either due to a technical deficiency, such as a tendency to walk across to off stump too far or leaving a gap between bat and pad when defending, which can be worked on and ironed out in the nets. The other way is mental, such as poor shot selection, getting stuck in the crease because you fear a short ball, getting stuck too rigidly into a defensive 'must not get out mode' when on a poor run on form etc. These are mental deficiencies which you cannot really work at in the nets so easily. That's what I was referring to when I said Hooper and Lara are roughly equal in the technical aspect, but Lara was streaks ahead mentally (add Bell in to the Hooper category too if you like).Errr, tough one. It's debateable whether being crap at cricket is classed as a mental affliction or not, but I don't think it's generally what people refer to when they use the word.
Seriously (i.e. no further critiques of his ability are required), why is McDonald on the tour?Aus squad for tomorrow's warm-up:
Phil Hughes
Simon Katich
Ricky Ponting (capt)
Mike Hussey
Michael Clarke
Marcus North
Brad Haddin
Mitchell Johnson
Brett Lee
Stuart Clark
Nathan Hauritz
Siddle rested and Hilfenhaus misses out.
Good point.Seriously (i.e. no further critiques of his ability are required), why is McDonald on the tour?
If they have no intention of playing him, then his position would've been better being taken by an extra batsman or spinner
Its either a paid holiday for a job done vs SA or an excuse not to pick the politically undesirable in the initial squad
It is a bit of a surprise, considering he's over there in the squad. Can only assume it means they don't intend playing him in at least the first two tests.Watson being unfit probably kills off Hauritz's Test chances.
WIth Watson at six, we could just have three specialist quicks, and then play Haurtiz.
By contrast, with no Watson, we'd be loathe to go in with just the three quicks (particularly as Clark and Lee don't have too many miles in their legs).
Anyway, shocked Ronny isn't playing tonight. Would rather him in the team than North.