• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

*Official* Third Test at Edgbaston

flibbertyjibber

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Strauss and Cook are too good to keep on failing, everyone knew that. Interesting that Strauss is having a poor series yet has the same amount of runs as Laxman who people are saying is one of the few bright lights for India. Shows the gulf in the teams really.
 

Prince EWS

Global Moderator
Strauss and Cook are too good to keep on failing, everyone knew that. Interesting that Strauss is having a poor series yet has the same amount of runs as Laxman who people are saying is one of the few bright lights for India. Shows the gulf in the teams really.
Shows the difference in the quality of bowling more than anything.
 

keeper

U19 Vice-Captain
Also, the signs were there for Strauss. It's not like SL, when he was really failing. Here he has been getting starts before getting out and came into the game one good performance away from a decent series average.
 

Spark

Global Moderator
Don't think you can go too hard at the Indian top-6, the English bowling was really good in the morning session. The dismissals aside, generally good balls following up good bowling (except for Dravid's which was just a jaffa), they made the Indians look tentative and sluggish.

Personally the only issue with Anderson's bowling has been that he's struggling a bit to deal with the amount of movement he's getting. He generally gets plenty because he's always looking for it but when the conditions do much of the work for you, reckon he sometimes struggles to just let it happen. That there is where Broad and Bresnan have him beat right now right.
I reckon he's been bowling a bit wide as well tbh. Maybe that has a bit to do with that.

Scary to think what England have achieved with their "best two bowlers" misfiring and basically nonexistent respectively.
 

Stapel

International Regular
Currently you'd have to say it'd be Shahzad, who's not having a great season.

What's he? Seventh? Current 3, Tremmers, Finn, Onions? Maybe eighth behind Dernbach now?
Which makes me wonder why Sidebottom is not considered by the selectors. Not too long ago he was England's mister-get-it-right.
Also, Chris Woakes might get into that list sooner or later.

Yeah, as harsh as it is, you can't leave Bres out. 11 wickets at less than 15 apiece in three innings is world class by any estimation. Add in 101 runs to boot.

Adds to the impression Tremmers is just a terribly unlucky player, but those are the breaks.
If Bopara (and/or Morgan) don't get too many runs, and Broad/Bresnan/Swann will, going in with 4 seamers and a spinner might be considered. Should be considered perhaps.

Not sure why its so hilarious to be honest. The thread was created before the start of the series, and there is not much doubt that before this series Broad, given the way hes bowled over his entire career, would not have made very many teams in the world. Lets be honest here, there is simply no precedent for him bowling the way he has this series. He's never managed to string 2 consistent games together all his life and here he is bowling like McGrath for 3 games in a row.
What I like(d) about Broad is that he had many decent, supporting and sometimes ordinary spells, suddenly exchanged for a brilliant spell. IMHO, that's match winning potential! Sure enough, his current form is extraordinary and indeed unprecedented, but I would have picked him anyway. England's attack is the best in the world (before this series), so if Broad made England's team before this series, he would have made any Test country's team.

Don't think you can go too hard at the Indian top-6, the English bowling was really good in the morning session. The dismissals aside, generally good balls following up good bowling (except for Dravid's which was just a jaffa), they made the Indians look tentative and sluggish.
Agree somewaht, but I must emphasize that the dismissals are what cricket is about. The Indian top batsmen should be able to handle some pressure and good bowling and NOT appear to look sluggish and tentative. I think they do deserve some criticism:
-Gambhir out to a loose drive
-Sehwag got out of the way halfheartedly
-Tendulkar could have left that delivery
-Laxman went for the hook, straight too a fielder set there for him.

Yeah, I think if we're still batting at the end of the day then India have a long climb back
I really hope this series offer us a nice twist, but I my money would be on England batting through the day and a good chunk of the 3rd day as well.
 

Manee

Cricketer Of The Year
He looked awful today. The way that he rolled out that slider/nothing ball first up was just awful.
India have not been proactive enough with selections. They should have seen that he bowled poor against West Indies and dropped him there. The same applies with Mukund. England are exponentially better than West Indies and India did not respond to poor performances against West Indies with enough urgency.
 

Uppercut

Request Your Custom Title Now!
I don't think it'll make that much difference, the pitch is so slow and they've wasted the new ball. The sun's due to come out some time during the morning session so if there are overcast conditions they'll need to make good use of them quickly.
 

Lillian Thomson

Hall of Fame Member
Had a txt from a mate at the ground saying there'd be no play before lunch and then Sky have just said they're starting at 11.30. Never trust a man with a beard.
 

Cevno

Hall of Fame Member
Sreesanth is so ****ing frustrating.

2/3 good balls then a loose one right on cue everytime.
 

Top