• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

*Official* NRL 2011 Season thread

howardj

International Coach
Is Nathan Brown and the Panthers the worst marriage ever?

The Panthers in my view need some discipline and maturity.

As coach, they need a Bobby Simpson/Mick Malthouse type character in charge.

Brown, top top bloke though he is, is an ill fit for such a role.
 

Ausage

Cricketer Of The Year
Is Nathan Brown and the Panthers the worst marriage ever?
Not perfect perhaps, but nowhere near the worst option being bandied about. People are suggesting Sticky Ricky FFS. All of the options are flawed in some way, Bennett has signed with Newcastle IIRC.

Brown was always going to have trouble at the Dragons coaching his mates and being younger than alot of them. Even then his results could be seen as disappointing rather than disastrous. Everyone talks like it was a travesty that the Dragons didn't win a comp in the mid 00s, but there were some seriously good teams with ATG players going around, and a couple that were either definitely or probably cheating the cap. He's 4 years older now, and hopefully a fair bit wiser.

He'll probably off to Salford or Widnes with Matty.
Probably. It's important to share body heat in the cold of an English winter.

On a lighter note, as a Tigers fan (you are a Tigers fan right?) how would you feel about the possibility of us nabbing Sheens?
 
Last edited:

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Would expect Brown to be a far better coach now than he was as a neophyte at the Dragons tbh.
 

howardj

International Coach
I do however stand by my previous remarks that to get the best out of Generation Y, you generally need authority - you need to rule by fear.

I give you Mick Malthouse, Wayne Bennett, Craig Belamy, Alex Ferguson, Des Hasler - all leaders in their field over the past few years.

Young blokes will just take advantage of you if you try to be their friend, or try to be on equal footing with them as coach.

You need to be formal in your dealings with younger players, and instil some fear.

This is something I touch on in my forthcoming essay on Australian cricket. Timmy Nielsen...do you think Steve Smith, Phil Hughes respect that bloke? Not a chance. You need an authority figure in there - someone with a bit of stature and authority; an Allan Border type if you will.
 

howardj

International Coach
It's true mate.

There's a real cancer in the NRL - teams just failing to show up every 2nd week or so.

Having a tough taskmaster/respected/feared figure as coach goes some way toward addressing that.
 

Ausage

Cricketer Of The Year
I do however stand by my previous remarks that to get the best out of Generation Y, you generally need authority - you need to rule by fear.
You only need to look at Penrith to see the truth of the above statement. As dire as we've looked as a footy team at times over the past four years, the worst thing about Elliott's time here is that he's been more of a mate than a coach.

Look at Petero. He's been running his mouth almost constantly over the past month or two about how the management of this club need to keep quiet, keep out of the media, keep Elliott, keep out of the footy team, keep doing THEIR job (read, not our job). He's outright criticizing his employer in public because the perfectly normal process in sport of being judged on your results is occuring with somebody he considers a close friend. He's one of the most experienced players in the game, he must know that these sorts of things happen to coaches just like they happen to players.

Look at Kingston this year if you want to see someone very comfortably coasting. The guy reeks of someone who isn't going to be dropped and knows it. Against Manly he made 2 forward passes from dummy half with 2 or 3 more that should have been pulled up and he's been doing it all year (along with showing absolutely zero creativity or energy). He didn't seem too phased though. There was no cursing or self admonition. He just blankly continued shoveling out slow barely legal passes. That kind of stuff just doesn't happen when you're paying attention, and you don't pay attention when you know your job is safe because your coach is your buddy first.

As an aside, afterward a young kid with everything to prove comes on and showed what can be done when you give a ****. Seluini looks a gun to me.

We reek of a club coasting on a good result last year, with no interesting putting in the very hard yards to get to that point again. Whoever comes in needs to kick that attitude as far away from the playing group as it can go.
 
Last edited:

howardj

International Coach
Oh FFS dude.
You only need to look at Penrith to see the truth of the above statement. As dire as we've looked as a footy team at times over the past four years, the worst thing about Elliott's time here is that he's been more of a mate than a coach.

.
Thank you.

I know it always sounds wanky, pontificating on Generation Y and psychology etc, but it's a point that needs to be made. The meek, weak Timmy Nielsen versus the wrath and authority of a Bobby Simpson or a Micky Malthouse, Leigh Matthews...common sense tells you it's a no contest in terms of respect and getting the best out of a team of young blokes.

As a coach....

- be a friend, that's a dead end
- be a taskmaster, that's what you're after!
 
Last edited:

Prince EWS

Global Moderator
Yeah I wasn't disagreeing with you howardj; I just couldn't believe you gave the thing yet another plug in the NRL thread of all places.
 

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Iirc that's more consecutive wins than anyone had last year all year. They're going along really well indeed. Good to see the filth beaten. No doubt they'll be bleating over a ref's call on Talkin' Bulldogs on the radio this arvo.

**** them. Very, very hard.
 

Mister Wright

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Iirc that's more consecutive wins than anyone had last year all year. They're going along really well indeed. Good to see the filth beaten. No doubt they'll be bleating over a ref's call on Talkin' Bulldogs on the radio this arvo.

**** them. Very, very hard.
From memory I think the Broncos and Dragons shared the longest winning streak last year of 5. Although, I think other than the Cowboys the Broncos also had the longest losing streak last year. Let's hope that pattern isn't repeated.
 

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Won't happen mate. They're a different kettle of fish this year. Would take a massive injury toll for that to happen IMHO.
 

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Cowboys show more ticker than I've seen from them in years. Meanwhile, Melbourne are so, so good. Such a shame they don't play Saints til about round 24.
 

Top