I do however stand by my previous remarks that to get the best out of Generation Y, you generally need authority - you need to rule by fear.
You only need to look at Penrith to see the truth of the above statement. As dire as we've looked as a footy team at times over the past four years, the worst thing about Elliott's time here is that he's been more of a mate than a coach.
Look at Petero. He's been running his mouth almost constantly over the past month or two about how the management of this club need to keep quiet, keep out of the media, keep Elliott, keep out of the footy team, keep doing THEIR job (read, not our job). He's outright criticizing his employer in public because the perfectly normal process in sport of being judged on your results is occuring with somebody he considers a close friend. He's one of the most experienced players in the game, he must know that these sorts of things happen to coaches just like they happen to players.
Look at Kingston this year if you want to see someone very comfortably coasting. The guy reeks of someone who isn't going to be dropped and knows it. Against Manly he made 2 forward passes from dummy half with 2 or 3 more that should have been pulled up and he's been doing it all year (along with showing absolutely zero creativity or energy). He didn't seem too phased though. There was no cursing or self admonition. He just blankly continued shoveling out slow barely legal passes. That kind of stuff just doesn't happen when you're paying attention, and you don't pay attention when you know your job is safe because your coach is your buddy first.
As an aside, afterward a young kid with everything to prove comes on and showed what can be done when you give a ****. Seluini looks a gun to me.
We reek of a club coasting on a good result last year, with no interesting putting in the very hard yards to get to that point again. Whoever comes in needs to kick that attitude as far away from the playing group as it can go.