NZ Guy
U19 Captain
Yeah but whose better? NO SINCLAIR. People on here said the same thing about Ross Taylor when he first came in, hes doing alright now. And yeah I did allude to the fact that ODI is not the same as test, his test form isn't too bad atm, his ODI is.He's a good one day batsman. Really has no business being in the Test team yet though. It's not the same thing.
The fact is he's definitely got the skills to perform at the top level, he just needs to learn how to build an innings and tbh I'd rather keep him in the team to have some sort of solidarity in the batting instead of just rotating the players like we do so well, the selectors keep getting criticized about there treatment of Sinclair yet we want the same thing to be done with Guptill, Flynn, Broom (maybe not this forum) etc.
Guptill is going to be a major component of our top/middle order with Williamson, Taylor, Ryder and McCullum in the not-to-distant future, can we please just stick with him? he's got the goods