Tom Curran over Brown/Mahmood surelyTalking about the batting lineup. Roy doesn't convince me at all. Banton is much younger and I think should be given a chance. I still think Roy can come in for Vince in the squad. Stokes comes in for Gregory. Archer in for Curran.
Roy
Banton
Malan
Morgan
Buttler
Stokes
Moeen
Archer
Jordan
Parkinson
Brown/Mahmood
Yes I think it's fair to say he's a legside dominant player. KP and Roy are the two players that he gets compared to a lot of which I'd concur with. He certainly isn't bad through the offside. He's not one of those guys with the strong bottom hand that impairs his offside game. Don't see Banton making the world t20 squad though given the mass of options England have at the top and Banton's lack of experience. He's playing in the Big Bash though so that should give him a chance if he scores runs.Banton looks really good. Just seems like a player who's been brought up on this format of the game.
I only saw some highlights of him in the Vitality and stuff, but he did seem like he favored the legside a lot. Going purely off the cricinfo commentary I think NZ knew that and bowled further outside off to him. Good to see him still crack most of his runs through the offside.
He would have to knock Bairstow out, possible looking at Bairstow's average t20 stats however Bairstow is a demon in the field so u need to factor that in. also Bairstow seems to be able to pressure the selectors into picking him in all the formats..i think it's a combination of a lot of factors and I don't necessarily disagree but as an outsider it's always a tad harshon competitiors like foakes and in this case banton potentially but I understand it and don't actually care either way at this point because baristow is a fierce competitor that is good to havein theside regardless of formYes I think it's fair to say he's a legside dominant player. KP and Roy are the two players that he gets compared to a lot of which I'd concur with. He certainly isn't bad through the offside. He's not one of those guys with the strong bottom hand that impairs his offside game. Don't see Banton making the world t20 squad though given the mass of options England have at the top and Banton's lack of experience. He's playing in the Big Bash though so that should give him a chance if he scores runs.
I'd definitely have Bairstow ahead of Banton. Bairstow record isn't great in T20is but he hasn't played that much over the last couple of years since his improvement in ODI cricket. Did have a brilliant IPL season this year which is probably the highest quality domestic t20 league. As you say he's also an excellent fielder. I also think he's capable of batting in the middle order as a finisher type, not just top order. His power play now is up there with some of the worlds best in terms of clearing the boundary consistently, and is also lightning between the wickets. Bairstow due to his multifaceted skills will definitely be part of the best 15 players England have.He would have to knock Bairstow out, possible looking at Bairstow's average t20 stats however Bairstow is a demon in the field so u need to factor that in. also Bairstow seems to be able to pressure the selectors into picking him in all the formats..i think it's a combination of a lot of factors and I don't necessarily disagree but as an outsider it's always a tad harshon competitiors like foakes and in this case banton potentially but I understand it and don't actually care either way at this point because baristow is a fierce competitor that is good to havein theside regardless of form
#mcgspectaclesobig#mcgsobig
My own inner dialogue predicted he would probably come back with "well we've got to play England first so focused on that" which I'd come back with "pfft those test easy beats? You'll walk it"He'd probably give a diplomatic answer to it though. Good question allround if you'd actually thought of it at the time.![]()
Thanks babeit's going to bucket down all day today