Can't help but be excited by England's batting options going into the 2019 WC. Theoretically the group should all still be improving upto 2019 (possibly with Morgan the only exception).
Billings played a very impressive knock yesterday in PSL. PLayed the spin really well. Has the big shots but also scores of most deliveries. Calm and composed. Looks to be on the verge of really breaking through but will he get the opportunity with England?
Still hard for him to get into the England ODI side. 8 into 7 doesn't go (or 6 into 5). Billings is going to put some serious pressure on Roy, Hales and Morgan for their spots but I don't think any of them really deserve to be dropped. Hales is the most vulnerable but Billings is best suited to the middle order. Hales (and Roy) is still a better opener imo. Billings if he played for a year I feel would be better than Morgan but that isn't going to happen.
The only way I could get Billings into the side is bring him in for Hales, promote Ali to open, and slot Billings in at 5 or 6 with Stokes dropping to 7. i.e Roy, Ali, Root, Morgan, Billings, Buttler, Stokes
It would make better use of Moeen's skills and the middle order would be a lot stronger and more adaptable. I can't see it happening though as they seem to have completely disregarded Moeen as a white ball opener.
There's no perfect solution though. Even with this team you'd have two openers who aren't really capable of going on. Too many 30,40s and not enough big hundreds and you want at least one of your openers capable of making those massive scores that settle games.
Billings in for Morgan would be the decision I'd make if the captaincy wasn't involved and it would be incredibly harsh on Morgan.
Stokes and Ali kind of get a free ride for their spots at the moment with England wanting the 6 bowlers. Stokes is improving as a bat, very good fielder and average to poor bowler so is guaranteed a spot. Moeen on the other hand could be vulnerable - his odi game has gone no-where. But Billings for Mo is a no go really giveen it leaves the bowling really light.