*Official* Australia in India 2023

[OverratedSanity]

Yes Carey should be sacked from his volunteer job as umpire.

You joke but reviewing is part of the job for a modern keeper. Stunned they didn't go for it.

 

[OverratedSanity]

Starc looks great so far

 

[Spark]

You joke but reviewing is part of the job for a modern keeper. Stunned they didn't go for it.

It is but it's alwayes irked me that we castigate players for being bad at umpiring when its the umpires themselves who are making the mistakes.

 

[harsh.ag]

Yes Carey should be sacked from his volunteer job as umpire.

Yes. Bring back the pain

 

[Test fan]

There is definitely some movement for first half hour so Australia need to take those chances

 

[Spark]

Cam Green needed to be fielding off his own bowling.

 

[Starfighter]

You joke but reviewing is part of the job for a modern keeper. Stunned they didn't go for it.

You only get practice for it in matches though.

Once again it needs to be stated - bad use of DRS doesn't excuse bad umpiring.

 

[Burgey]

Starc looks great so far

Yeah he's been terrific. Be interesting to see how he goes as the day gets on, he's well short of a gallop, but he's been really good the past 12 months or so in tests.

 

[harsh.ag]

It's even worse umpiring in the days of the DRS. You give these kind of appeals out, and if the batter hasn't knicked it, he will review, since the batsman always (or almost always) knows.

 

[Test fan]

It is but it's alwayes irked me that we castigate players for being bad at umpiring when its the umpires themselves who are making the mistakes.

Umprire are humans so they did make mistakes that's why technology is here to use

 

[morgieb]

Anyone else having issues with Kayo?

 

[Burgey]

Umprire are humans so they did make mistakes that's why technology is here to use

lol so do players. The caught behind was an abject howler, let's be honest.

Green's been a bit too full so far.

Like to see Starc have a crack at Gill early with the shape he's getting. be a good contest.

 

[Spark]

Yeah Green looks short of a gallop, as expected. Overpitching.

 

[OverratedSanity]

It is but it's alwayes irked me that we castigate players for being bad at umpiring when its the umpires themselves who are making the mistakes.

You only get practice for it in matches though.

Once again it needs to be stated - bad use of DRS doesn't excuse bad umpiring.

Well no **** the umpires suck. Australia not reviewing is objectively the funnier aspect of this so don't pretend you don't know why people focus on that more than the umpires. Its hilarious that's why.

 

[Burgey]

Anyone else having issues with Kayo?

It's ok here atm. Streaming via the laptop in the office.

 

[Starfighter]

Umprire are humans so they did make mistakes that's why technology is here to use

Idiotic argument. The umpires are in the best position to make the decision.

 

[Test fan]

lol so do players. The caught behind was an abject howler, let's be honest.

Green's been a bit too full so far.

Like to see Starc have a crack at Gill early with the shape he's getting. be a good contest.

11 player's vs 1 umpire. No camparsion at all

 

[Gob]

How could they not review either of those

 

[Nintendo]

These two have both bowled well so far, particularly starc. Created plenty of chances and somehow India are going at 5's and haven't lost a wicket. Fickle game.

 

[Burgey]

To say there's value for shot at this ground is quite the understatement.