age_master
Hall of Fame Member
well im happy, dont piticularly like him anyway,, not sure wether they should send clarke or katich over to replace him though
He is, he's only had one good season remember...Tim said:Clarke has played about 3 seasons of first class cricket, so he's not being rushed at all.
Nope they seem to think he's a OD utility player and that's it. But he's got a proven record in 4D cricket, as has one of the most unlucky players at the moment, Mike Hussey. Both would have been more understandable picks but the selectors got carried away in the excitement that a young player finally had a good season...lord_of_darkness said:yea i do not know much of clarke ,
what about maher i think he is quite a good batsmen is he in the tour ?
He had a good year last year as well.Rik said:He is, he's only had one good season remember...
It's all well and good quoting his one day stats and how he outscored others in one day cricket, but he's been called up to the Test leg of the tour!age_master said:Clarke is a good batsman, averaged 55 in OD and 47.5 or something in 4d this season, NSW leading run scorer in OD - ahead of players like Mark Waugh
Well I've been talking to Andre and he can't understand why he's been called up, as there are many other players who have done much better for much longer than he has. Andre also can't understand why you talk about his bowling all the time Age, he says he's seen it and you can find better pies in the local butchers...Eclipse said:He had a good year last year as well.
I remember him making 2 hundreds in the Pura Cup last year and one in the ING cup and over all he was very good last year.
I would normaly agree with you about a player needing to establish himsefl a little more but IMO there is no doubt at all he will be an exellent test and ODI player for Australia and when you actualy get a chance to see him bat you will understand what all the fuss is about.
For the record I would rate Hussey, Bevan, Law, Maher, Elliot and Katich as much more deserving players. I feel that the selectors have just been carried away in the excitement just like Rooney with England in the football, and after what I heard was a good performance everyone realises he's only 17 and can't play every game.broncoman said:Clarke has done enough to be given his spot, hes been the next best batsman all season and is not there only on his age, he is in the top 7-8 batsmen now, no doubt.
Rik said:For the record I would rate Hussey, Bevan, Law, Maher, Elliot and Katich as much more deserving players. I feel that the selectors have just been carried away in the excitement just like Rooney with England in the football, and after what I heard was a good performance everyone realises he's only 17 and can't play every game.
Bevan: Averages over 50 every season for NSW and has a career average of 56, and yet he is branded a OD specialist.age_master said:Bevan has hasd his shot at test level, and hes reasonably old now too, they are trying to let abit of young blood into the side as well
Law- HE CANT EVEN GET A CONSTANT PLACE IN TEH QLD SIDE
Maher - more a OD player - averages about 42 in 4d i tthink, hes good, but not as good as clarke
Elliot - has had his shot too - and hes an opening batsman, we got enough of them with hayden, langer and love - unfortunate end to his career, but well, it happens
Katich and Hussey - would have been my 2nd and 3rd picks respectivley, they are both 6 or 7 years older, hussey has not had his best year, though they are both in england (closer to the WI) katich has been bowling well this year but his batting wasn't as good as it has been.
clarke however has been in good form with the bat - in his 2nd last game he and steve waugh smashed the QLD attack all over the park - steve waugh's SR was about 75 and clarkes was over 100 clarke also made a few runs towards the end of te ING cup - he didn't bat in the final