Kane Williamson vs Everton Weekes

[Johan]

monsters at home, but a bit middling away from home.

 

[DrWolverine]

Everton Weeks feasted on the minnows(Ind, Pak & NZ). Out of his 15 centuries, he scored 11 in 21 matches against them.

Weeks:
vs Aus : 40
vs Eng : 45
in Aus : 24
in Eng : 33

 

[Johan]

funnily, Kane gets quite a bit of **** for his home/away record but some players with similar records are considered ATG.

 

[Coronis]

Something something pretty batsman, something something strike rate. Something something wasn’t even the best of the W’s.

 

[BazBall21]

Something something pretty batsman, something something strike rate. Something something wasn’t even the best of the W’s.

Walcott has the best resume because of his series v Australia

 

[Coronis]

Walcott has the best resume because of his series v Australia

Yeah I’ve always rated Walcott highest of the 3.

 

[Red_Ink_Squid]

Everton Weeks feasted on the minnows

An accusation which thankfully has never been brought against Williamson.

 

[sayon basak]

An accusation which thankfully has never been brought against Woakes.

Fixed. You're welcome.

 

[DrWolverine]

An accusation which thankfully has never been brought against Williamson.

Williamson
vs Aus : 37
vs Ind : 37
vs SA : 50
vs Pak : 53
vs SL : 59

I do not rate Kane that highly but he played against a higher level of competition. I guess you could say that for most players post-1970s.

 

[kyear2]

funnily, Kane gets quite a bit of **** for his home/away record but some players with similar records are considered ATG.

Don't think most would consider Weekes an ATG

 

[Coronis]

Don't think most would consider Weekes an ATG

Depends where people’s ATG cut off is. I know the poll this year had him at #22. I’ve usually seen him ranked somewhere in the 20-25 range in most lists in the past, depends how many ATGs people have.

 

[BazBall21]

Don't think most would consider Weekes an ATG

Think the Ws tend to be awarded that status

 

[kyear2]

Think the Ws tend to be awarded that status

Not by me, so

 

[h_hurricane]

Williamson for his 30 wickets, 19 of which came away from home.

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Average of 58 is probably ATG in Weekes’s era

 

[Johan]

Average of 58 is probably ATG in Weekes’s era

if they both were as good as their numbers suggest they'd be second to Bradman in conversation

 

[kyear2]

if they both were as good as their numbers suggest they'd be second to Bradman in conversation

Which is not nearly the case.