Jacques Kallis vs Younis Khan

[Coronis]

I feel like a definition of ATG that excludes a batsmen who scored 10k runs and averaged 52, and scored tons in all 11 possible countries where he played tests is a bit restrictive.

But that’s just me.

 

[kyear2]

I feel like a definition of ATG that excludes a batsmen who scored 10k runs and averaged 52, and scored tons in all 11 possible countries where he played tests is a bit restrictive.

But that’s just me.

I think it's supposed to be exclusive. If there's 100 if them it means less.

For me it's the very best of the very best.

But everyone's criteria would be different.

 

[Coronis]

I think it's supposed to be exclusive. If there's 100 if them it means less.

For me it's the very best of the very best.

But everyone's criteria would be different.

Nobody said 100. Which would anyway, be just over 3% of test players. Sounds exclusive to me.

 

[Johan]

I feel like a definition of ATG that excludes a batsmen who scored 10k runs and averaged 52, and scored tons in all 11 possible countries where he played tests is a bit restrictive.

But that’s just me.

he is a bit like Cook for me, just with Inflated stats.

 

[kyear2]

Nobody said 100. Which would anyway, be just over 3% of test players. Sounds exclusive to me.

But it's supposed to be.