High time ICC have a check on the umpires

[shankar]

Hawkeye doesn't pick up snicks.

True. My argument is only that the hawk-eye is far more accurate in predicting the ball's path than the umpire.

 

[marc71178]

And I disagree - and since there is not any technology that can accurately prove the ball's path or accurately prove a nick has been made, it should not be brought in.

 

[shankar]

And I disagree - and since there is not any technology that can accurately prove the ball's path or accurately prove a nick has been made, it should not be brought in.

To me its not 100% but obviously far better than than the umpire for the reasons I mentioned earlier. But we've argued this to the ground and it's getting really boring. So agree to disagree?

 

[Lions81]

Yes, I know. I've worked with computers for 25 years and they are still all out to get me.