All picks
| 1 | trundler | Imran Khan |
| 2 | Teuton | Kapil Dev |
| 3 | hb | Adam Gilchrist |
| 4 | Fuller Pilch | SF Barnes |
| 5 | Bitmap | Richard Hadlee |
| 6 | Mags | Pat Cummins |
| 7 | AndrewB | Malcolm Marshall |
| 8 | Himannv | Glenn McGrath |
| 9 | Pothas | Garfield Sobers |
| 10 | CricAddict | Jack Hobbs |
| 11 | Howe | Curtly Ambrose |
| 12 | AnkitJ | Dale Steyn |
| 13 | GIMH | Shane Warne |
| 14 | Marcuss | Bill O'Reilly |
| 15 | ataraxia | Joe Root |
| 16 | Brumby | Len Hutton |
| 17 | Brumby | Herbert Sutcliffe |
| 18 | ataraxia | Sachin Tendulkar |
| 19 | Marcuss | Denis Compton |
| 20 | GIMH | Brian Lara |
| 21 | AnkitJ | Sunil Gavaskar |
| 22 | Howe | Keith Miller |
| 23 | CricAddict | Viv Richards |
| 24 | Pothas | Muttiah Muralitharan |
| 25 | Himannv | Wasim Akram |
| 26 | AndrewB | Jacques Kallis. |
| 27 | Mags | Elysse Perry |
| 28 | Bitmap | Steve Smith |
| 29 | Fuller Pilch | Allan Border |
| 30 | hb | Ravi Ashwin |
| 31 | Teuton | Clyde Walcott |
| 32 | trundler | Ricky Ponting |
| 33 | AnkitJ | Dennis Lillee |
| 34 | Mags | AB de Villiers |
| 35 | Pothas | Shaun Pollock |
| 36 | Bitmap | Waqar Younis |
| 37 | hb | Kagiso Rabada |
| 38 | Himannv | Ian Botham |
| 39 | Brumby | Fred Trueman |
| 40 | Howe | Virender Sehwag |
| 41 | Marcuss | Ray Lindwall |
| 42 | ataraxia | Javed Miandad |
| 43 | AndrewB | Ken Barrington |
| 44 | GIMH | Matthew Hayden |
| 45 | Teuton | Ravindra Jadeja |
| 46 | trundler | Joel Garner |
| 47 | CricAddict | Steve Waugh |
| 48 | Fuller Pilch | Greg Chappell |
| 49 | Fuller Pilch | Alan Davidson |
| 50 | CricAddict | Kumar Sangakkara |
| 51 | trundler | Gordon Greenidge |
| 52 | Teuton | Victor Trumper |
| 53 | GIMH | Rahul Dravid |
| 54 | AndrewB | Ian Bishop |
| 55 | ataraxia | Mushtaq Mohammad |
| 56 | Marcuss | Everton Weekes |
| 57 | Howe | James Anderson |
| 58 | Brumby | Jim Laker |
| 59 | Himannv | Wally Hammond |
| 60 | hb | Shakib Al Hasan |
| 61 | Bitmap | Bob Simpson |
| 62 | Pothas | Geoffrey Boycott |
| 63 | Mags | Frank Worrell |
| 64 | AnkitJ | Neil Harvey |
| 65 | Brumby | Michael Clarke |
| 66 | hb | Mitchell Johnson |
| 67 | Bitmap | Younis Khan |
| 68 | Teuton | Alec Bedster |
| 69 | Howe | Alan Knott |
| 70 | Fuller Pilch | Allan Donald |
| 71 | Magrat Garlick | Bob Willis |
| 72 | CricAddict | Ben Stokes |
| 73 | AndrewB | Les Ames |
| 74 | Himannv | Kane Williamson |
| 75 | AnkitJ | Clarrie Grimmett |
| 76 | trundler | Michael Holding |
| 77 | ataraxia | Wes Hall |
| 78 | Marcuss | Graeme Pollock |
| 79 | Pothas | Jasprit Bumrah |
| 80 | GIMH | Matt Prior |
| 81 | GIMH | Mohammed Asif |
| 82 | Pothas | Inzamam-ul-Haq |
| 83 | Marcuss | Barry Richards |
| 84 | ataraxia | Conrad Hunte |
| 85 | trundler | Clive Lloyd |
| 86 | AnkitJ | Shivnarine Chanderpaul |
| 87 | Himannv | Rohan Kanhai |
| 88 | AndrewB | Johnny Wardle |
| 89 | CricAddict | Derek Underwood |
| 90 | Mags | Graeme Smith |
| 91 | Fuller Pilch | WG Grace |
| 92 | Howe | Kevin Pietersen |
| 93 | Teuton | Peter May |
| 94 | Bitmap | Courtney Walsh |
| 95 | hb | Jason Gillespie |
| 96 | Brumby | George Headley |
| 97 | Marcuss | Andy Roberts |
| 98 | Mags | Dudley Nourse |
| 99 | Bitmap | Bruce Mitchell |
| 100 | Howe | Mohammed Yousuf |
| 101 | Teuton | David Warner |
| 102 | GIMH | Shane Bond |
| 103 | ataraxia | Farokh Engineer |
| 104 | CricAddict | Hanif Mohammed |
| 105 | Pothas | VVS Laxman |
| 106 | Himannv | Anil Kumble |
| 107 | hb | Wasim Raja |
| 108 | Fuller Pilch | Subhash Gupte |
| 109 | Brumby | Rishabh Pant |
| 110 | trundler | Virat Kohli |
| 111 | AndrewB | Graham Gooch |
| 112 | AnkitJ | Martin Crowe |
| 113 | AnkitJ | Vernon Philander |
| 114 | AndrewB | Arthur Morris |
| 115 | trundler | Rangana Herath |
| 116 | Brumby | Mahela Jayawardene |
| 117 | Fuller Pilch | Clem Hill |
| 118 | hb | Shane Watson |
| 119 | Himannv | |
| 120 | Pothas | |
| 121 | CricAddict | |
| 122 | ataraxia | |
| 123 | GIMH | |
| 124 | Teuton | |
| 125 | Howe | |
| 126 | Bitmap | |
| 127 | Mags | |
| 128 | Marcuss |
