England's best Oneday batsmen?

[weldone]

No. 66 ODIs isn't really enough to judge a player on, IMO.

Well, considering that England hasn't produced a Viv Richards or a Sachin Tendulkar (or even a Zaheer Abbas or a Brian Lara) in ODI cricket, one might consider amazing performances in 66 ODIs enough to be compared to any English ODI batsman in history...Again, I agree it is purely subjective...

 

[weldone]

M. Trescothick

Oops, I must have forgotten about Pietersen when I made that post...

Edit: Oh, not that, but that post was made 1 year ago...

 

[zaremba]

Pietersen

and then not much to choose between the runners-up:

Gooch
Trescothick
Knight
Lamb
Faibrother
Hick

 

[Matt79]

Having recently had to spend quite a bit of time pondering this for the Mystery Draft, I re-endorse my comment of 14 months ago, but remove the qualification. It's Pietersen, then daylight, then Tresco/Knight/Lamb for mine all in a group.

 

[Prince EWS]

To me it will always be Graham Gooch and Allan Lamb.

You really want a ban, don't ya?

 

[Richard]

Amazing how many dass\deira\Mard threads he's dug. I guess he always wants the ban in the end.