Battle of the AFL Stars

[Johnners]

Carey

 

[vic_orthdox]

Haha, toughie.

One on one, Jako probably had it over Carey more often. Two premierships vs two premierships. Let me stew over it and I'll get back to you tomorrow.

 

[dontcloseyoureyes]

Carey.

 

[Buddhmaster]

Jako more often than not got the better of Carey, but Carey's the best player ever.

Wayne Carey

 

[Jono]

Jacko definitely had the wood over Carey, probably my favourite battle to watch in football alongside Silvagni vs. Ablett.

Carey was the better player though.

 

[pasag]

Darren says:
carey obviously, but sheeze

 

[Hoggy31]

The Final List has been made. There are players who've missed out, who could've definetly been in there, but such is life, and as we'll all agree on it'll make little difference to the final outcome.

1.Wayne Carey - North Melbourne Kangaroos/Adelaide Crows - Centre Half Foward
2.Michael Voss - Brisbane Lions - Midfield
3.James Hird - Essendon Bombers - Half Foward/Midfield
4.Nathan Buckley - Collingwood Magpies/Brisbane Bears - Midfield
5.Chris Judd - West Coast Eagles - Midfield
6.Jonathon Brown - Brisbane Lions - Centre Half Foward
7.Tony Lockett - St Kilda/Sydney(Sydney only in the selected period) Full Foward
8.Ben Cousins - West Coast Eagles - Midfield
9.Andrew McLeod - Adelaide Crows - Midfield/Halfback
10.Mark Ricciuto - Adelaide Crows - Midfield
11.Jason Akermanis - Brisbane Lions - Midfield
12.Matthew Lloyd - Essendon Bombers - Full Foward
13.David Neitz - Melbourne Demons -Full Foward
14.Scott West - Western Bulldogs - Midfield
15.Brad Johnson - Western Bulldogs - Midfield/Foward Pocket
16.Warren Tredrea - Port Adelaide Power - Centre Half Foward
17.Gavin Wanganeen - Essendon Bombers/Port Adelaide Power
18.Robert Harvey - St. Kilda - Midfield
19.Shane Crawford - Hawthorn Hawks - Midfield
20.Matthew Pavlich - Fremantle Dockers - Centre Half Foward
21.Adams Goodes - Sydney Swans - Midfield
22.Anthony Koutoufides - Carlton Blues - Midfield
23.Chris Grant - Western Bulldogs - Half Foward
24.Peter Bell - North Melbourne Kangaroos/Fremantle Dockers - Midfield
25.Stephen Silvagni - Carlton Blues - Fullback
26.Simon Black - Brisbane Lions - Midfield
27.Justin Leppitch - Brisbane Lions - Halfback
28.Alastair Lynch - Brisbane Lions - Full Foward
29.Glen Jakovich - West Coast Eagles - Centre Halfback
30.Nigel Lappin - Brisbane Lions - Midfield
31.Duncan Fletcher - Essendon Bombers - Fullback
32.Shaun Rehn - Adelaide - Ruck

updated for the final time ffs. Peter bell for Ratten.

Chris Johnson>Leppa.

Carey. Just end voting now, tbh.

 

[Johnners]

note, if anyone else has a cry about who's in the battle, David Schwarze will replace Wayne Carey.

 

[Jono]

Haha, Ox is hilarious on SEN, so I wouldn't mind that

 

[Matteh]

note, if anyone else has a cry about who's in the battle, David Schwarze will replace Wayne Carey.

Seriously though, no Pickett? Ridiculous.

 

[vic_orthdox]

Seriously though, no Pickett? Ridiculous.

You shut your mouth when you're talking to me.

Jakovich deserves a vote, considering he had the wood over Carey.

 

[cameeel]

Agree with Matteh, Pickett should be in there over Lynch or Fletcher.

 

[Linda]

Alright, I'll vote for Jacko. Mostly a pity vote, but also because he's a ****ing legend.

 

[Johnners]

Agree with Matteh, Pickett should be in there over Lynch or Fletcher.

No vote in this battle?

 

[oz_fan]

Wayne Carey

 

[Hoggy31]

Agree with Matteh, Pickett should be in there over Lynch or Fletcher.

Haha, gotta be joking, right?

 

[cameeel]

No vote in this battle?

Didn't even look at the previous page tbh.

Jakovich

 

[cameeel]

Haha, gotta be joking, right?

Pickett's a hell of a lot better than Lynch was.

 

[Johnners]

*sigh*Borcich has asked for Leppa to be replaced by Johnson. I will only do so if there is a majority who agree. Otherwise, nothing will change.

 

[FaaipDeOiad]

Modra > Neitz/Lynch

Anyway, Carey.