FORMER Australia skipper Greg Chappell is concerned the country's next generation of cricketers isn't being tested by the best at domestic level and believes this could explain why Australia's production line has faltered in recent years.
Chappell has noticed that international players aren’t playing as much domestic cricket as they once did and are unlikely to do so in the future.
But he believes Cricket Australia has taken a proactive step to address this issue by boosting its investment in Under-19 cricket, The Futures League and the Australia A program.
This year the Australian Under-19 team has toured New Zealand and India, while Australia A has travelled to England and South Africa as part of an expanded program.
"What this means is that our next generation of players is being exposed to higher levels of competition in a variety of conditions in an attempt to accelerate their learning and to prepare them for even higher levels of competition," Chappell said on cricket.com.au.
Chappell was responding to criticism from former first-class cricketers Theo Doropolous and Dirk Nannes, who said restrictions to the number of players over the age of 23 is the sole reason for Australia's current problems.
"I wish it was that simple," Chappell said.
Concerned with Australia’s ageing batting line-up back in 2008, a restriction was placed on the number of over-23 players playing in what was then called the Futures League. Only three players out of 12 were allowed to be over 23.
Two years later the restrictions were relaxed for the 2011-2012 season to allow six players over the age of 23 to play.
Chappell says the restrictions have had a profound effect on the number of Under-23 players being contracted by the States.
"This season, there are 17 batsmen under the age of 23 on State contracts," he said.
"That is an increase of 90 per cent in the five years of the restrictions.
"I would argue that not having the restrictions in place was hurting Australia more than the restrictions are. In fact, everything that I know about the development process for producing talent reinforces this."
Doropolous and Nannes argued that experienced players are vital for the domestic competition and Chappell agrees, but only to an extent.
"My reservation is that experience is overrated," he said.
"In fact, a lot of players who have been around for any length of time and who are not progressing in their own game may not be the right players at all.
"Experience is important, but so is youthful experience and enthusiasm; when one has a desire to learn, one creates experience at a higher level.
"We only have six States, so it is imperative that we have more than nine batsmen under 23 at any given time or the pain we are currently experiencing will be nothing compared with what we might expect in the future."