Slow Love™
International Captain
I think the deadness of the pitches has probably extended the contests to a fair degree. Not to take away from some of the English performances with the bat, but I think it's been very difficult for the bowlers for quite long stretches of play, particularly towards the tail of the matches (the last day at Adelaide obviously being an aberration more revolving around the attitudes of the players concerned more than the pitch itself) - and England's bowling form, apart from one or two flashes (and discounting Panesar) has been frequently indifferent.
They haven't been absolutely caned in every session of the match, and they've certainly won sessions, but I wouldn't call the series much of a contest so far. If you look at our tour of Sri Lanka, where we also won 3-0, that was actually far more of a contest, because you could easily see us losing any of those games at particular points. Doesn't feel that way (to me at least) here at all. And things will only look worse if this goes to 5-0, as it well might. The final margins of each test are very conclusive.
Paradoxically (or not), we may see more of a contest now that the final two tests are dead rubbers, but as I said earlier, I think the Aussies are very committed to humiliating England further, and unless they take their feet off the pedal, I suspect it will run that way.
South Africa was more competitive, IMO. They drew a live test, and the third one Smith effectively threw away. The result probably should have been 1-0.
They haven't been absolutely caned in every session of the match, and they've certainly won sessions, but I wouldn't call the series much of a contest so far. If you look at our tour of Sri Lanka, where we also won 3-0, that was actually far more of a contest, because you could easily see us losing any of those games at particular points. Doesn't feel that way (to me at least) here at all. And things will only look worse if this goes to 5-0, as it well might. The final margins of each test are very conclusive.
Paradoxically (or not), we may see more of a contest now that the final two tests are dead rubbers, but as I said earlier, I think the Aussies are very committed to humiliating England further, and unless they take their feet off the pedal, I suspect it will run that way.
South Africa was more competitive, IMO. They drew a live test, and the third one Smith effectively threw away. The result probably should have been 1-0.