All-Time South Africa XIs - A re-run

[capt_Luffy]

From draft experience, he normally logs off around now

Yeah, was also thinking the same. Only one position is close and his vote would have been the tie breaker. Guess in the next round, will post the results in a moment.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Jackie McGlew - 6
Jimmy Cook - 3
Kepler Wessels - 3

Lee Irvine - 5
Faf du Plessis - 1

Reggie Schwarz - 5
John Traicos - 1

And while FP voted for Ntini, he initially voted for FDV. Otoh, Northerner switched his from Ntini to Morkel, leading Morkel ahead.

 

[capt_Luffy]

South Africa XI	South Africa A	South Africa B	South Africa C
1. BA Richards	1. B Mitchell	1. EJ Barlow	1. DJ McGlew
2. GC Smith*	2. TL Goddard*	2. HH Gibbs	2.
3. JH Kallis	3. G Kirsten	3. EAB Rowan	3.
4. RG Pollock	4. HM Amla	4. DJ Culinan	4.
5. AD Nourse	5. HW Taylor	5. KC Bland	5. BL Irvine
6. GA Faulkner	6. AB de Villiers	6. Q de Kock+	6.
7. JHB Waite+	7. DT Lindsay+	7. BM McMillan	7.
8. SM Pollock	8. MJ Procter	8. AEE Vogler	8.
9. HJ Tayfield	9. KA Maharaj	9. VD Philander	9. R Schwarz
10. DW Steyn	10. NAT Adcock	10.PM Pollock	10.
11. AA Donald	11. K Rabada	11.M Morkel	11.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Now please vote for:
A) One among Cook or Wessels. Again, mostly for @Line and Length, though votes can be switched and new voters are welcomed.
B) Two opening bowlers
C) The wicketkeeper

 

[Teuton]

Wessels again
Ntini
Fanie
Boucher

 

[ataraxia]

Ntini
de Villiers

Cameron

 

[capt_Luffy]

Wessels again
Ntini
Fanie
Boucher

No need to vote again, though appreciated. Already counting yours from the previous one as you did, unless you want to switch.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Makhaya Ntini
Fanie de Villiers

Jock Cameron

 

[Northerner]

Cook
Boucher
Ntini
DeVilliers

 

[Bitmap]

Ntini
de Villiers

Cameron

This for me

 

[Line and Length]

Cook

Ntini
P.Heine

Boucher

 

[capt_Luffy]

Last vote @Fuller Pilch

 

[Flametree]

Cameron, Ntini, de Villiers. Will not pick an opener as I'd have Melville ahead of either...

 

[CricAddict]

Wessels
Nitni
Fanie
Boucher

 

[Fuller Pilch]

Wessels (although good point above about Melville - esp as Wessels batted better for Aus than he did for SA)
Ntini
FDV
Cameron

 

[Thala_0710]

Wessels
Ntini
De Villiers
Boucher

 

[capt_Luffy]

Wessels wins this by 2-1 votes.

Makhaya Ntini - 10
Fanie de Villiers - 9
Peter Heine - 1

Jock Cameron - 5
Mark Boucher - 5

 

[capt_Luffy]

South Africa XI	South Africa A	South Africa B	South Africa C
1. BA Richards	1. B Mitchell	1. EJ Barlow	1. DJ McGlew
2. GC Smith*	2. TL Goddard*	2. HH Gibbs	2. KC Wessels
3. JH Kallis	3. G Kirsten	3. EAB Rowan	3.
4. RG Pollock	4. HM Amla	4. DJ Culinan	4.
5. AD Nourse	5. HW Taylor	5. KC Bland	5. BL Irvine
6. GA Faulkner	6. AB de Villiers	6. Q de Kock+	6.
7. JHB Waite+	7. DT Lindsay+	7. BM McMillan	7.
8. SM Pollock	8. MJ Procter	8. AEE Vogler	8.
9. HJ Tayfield	9. KA Maharaj	9. VD Philander	9. R Schwarz
10. DW Steyn	10. NAT Adcock	10.PM Pollock	10. PS de Villiers
11. AA Donald	11. K Rabada	11.M Morkel	11. M Ntini

 

[capt_Luffy]

Now please vote for:

A) One of the keepers among Boucher and Cameron, for those who haven't. In case of a draw again, the one who has received overall more votes all rounds combined will get ahead, given no one has any objections to it.
B) Two Middle order batsmen to bat at 3 and 4.
C) Another bowler
D) The last player to complete the team.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Jimmy Cook
Faf du Plessis


Jimmy Blackenbberg
Dave Nourse