Yeah, completely agree. I actually did love it on release, but was a teenage fanboy who was depressed because the whites had lost at Wembley the day before. When the dust settled, I decided it wasn't much cop. Been listening to them more than ever the past few months and appreciating parts of it more than ever.
Worth noting, by the way, that a lot of the biggest fans of it that I've come across on that forum, are people who are relative newcomers as oasis fans, i.e. people who got hooked in around Don't Believe The Truth in 2005 (younger people, usually). I think that tells you a quite lot as well, as you've said it's the most 'out there' and a lot of people were just like wtf is this, because it didn't meet expectations. You don't have that same prejudice when you do a band's back catalogue in one go.