Abdul Qadir vs Subhash Gupte

[sayon basak]

My vote is for @sayon basak 's father

Abdul Qadir might be a bit better than Warne.........who didn't have a proper googly, usually bowled in the rough and is generally overrated.

 

[Thala_0710]

Just think he is the single most overrated cricketer in the history of the sport and Gupte is closer to any spinner who isn't Warne-Murali-O'Reilly, than to him. Actually the 3 out of 6 voted were kind of meme ones here.

Overrated by the general public? Definitely

 

[Johan]

switched to ABD btw

Switch back to Compton

also, you rated Compton above ABD in the Three Ws + Harvey + May/Compton rating we did.

 

[sayon basak]

Just think he is the single most overrated cricketer in the history of the sport and Gupte is closer to any spinner who isn't Warne-Murali-O'Reilly, than to him. Actually the 3 out of 6 voted were kind of meme ones here.

Gupte is better than Warne.

 

[Johan]

@sayon basak I've switched back, you better do it too or...

 

[sayon basak]

@sayon basak I've switched back, you better do it too or...

Subhash Gupte was the best leg spinner.

Subhash Gupte>Abdul Qadir>Shane Warne.

 

[Johan]

Subhash Gupte was the best leg spinner.

Subhash Gupte>Abdul Qadir>Shane Warne.

switched to Gupte

 

[sayon basak]

switched to Gupte

Gupte was the greatest leg-spinner ever, well ahead of Warne who didn't have a proper googly, resorted to bowling into the rough, and was generally overrated.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Overrated by the general public? Definitely

General public some. And by ex players egregiously so. Especially Benaud and Gooch, it's just yucky.

 

[Coronis]

iirc Clarrie Grimmett didn’t have a proper legbreak, he just kept bowling the flipper. Piss poor spinner

 

[capt_Luffy]

iirc Clarrie Grimmett didn’t have a proper legbreak, he just kept bowling the flipper. Piss poor spinner

Don knew that Frank Ward was better.