• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Viv Richards vs steve smith

Who had better peak

  • Viv

    Votes: 15 39.5%
  • Smith

    Votes: 23 60.5%

  • Total voters
    38

Johan

International Captain
including WSC (Lillee and Imran played it), Viv's numbers would be

3,513 @ 49.47, with 8 tons.

for reference, Sachin against the elite ATGs of his time (McG, Amb, that Pakistani ball tamperer, Donald, Steyn)

2,679 @ 39.98, with 9 tons

Lara against great bowlers of his time (pakistan ball tampering duo, Donald, McGrath)

3,116 @ 40.46, with 6 tons

not half bad for a goober like Viv
Gooch TOAA

 

Johan

International Captain
including WSC (Lillee and Imran played it), Viv's numbers would be

3,513 @ 49.47, with 8 tons.

for reference, Sachin against the elite ATGs of his time (McG, Amb, that Pakistani ball tamperer, Donald, Steyn)

2,679 @ 39.98, with 9 tons

Lara against great bowlers of his time (pakistan ball tampering duo, Donald, McGrath)

3,116 @ 40.46, with 6 tons

not half bad for a goober like Viv
Root vs Cummins, Rabada and Bumrah

3,782 @ 46.7 with 9 tons


not bad for a guy who apparently can't play fast bowling
 

DrWolverine

International Debutant
W
including WSC (Lillee and Imran played it), Viv's numbers would be

3,513 @ 49.47, with 8 tons.

for reference, Sachin against the elite ATGs of his time (McG, Amb, that Pakistani ball tamperer, Donald, Steyn)

2,679 @ 39.98, with 9 tons

Lara against great bowlers of his time (pakistan ball tampering duo, Donald, McGrath)

3,116 @ 40.46, with 6 tons

not half bad for a goober like Viv
What about Sunny against Pace Quartet, Imran, Hadlee and Lillee?
 

capt_Luffy

International Coach

Johan

International Captain
Gavaskar played 3 Tests vs Imran before 78, and Imran was pretty good there, as was Nawaz really. It wasn't like very early career Imran.
Also, you forgot Marshall.
His average becomes 42-43 without that series which is fine, the series was very flat though iirc.

for the 78 series, after that when Marshall actually became a good bowler, they played 10 games, and you know those games very well.
 

capt_Luffy

International Coach
His average becomes 42-43 without that series which is fine, the series was very flat though iirc.

for the 78 series, after that when Marshall actually became a good bowler, they played 10 games, and you know those games very well.
Yeah it was flat, but Pakistani bowlers Nawaz and Imran did quite well there, compared to Indian ones where all averaged 48+

Pretty sure Gavaskar vs Marshall in 78 isn't the only one to play an ATG before them becoming an ATG or then passed their heydays......
 

Johan

International Captain
Yeah it was flat, but Pakistani bowlers Nawaz and Imran did quite well there, compared to Indian ones where all averaged 48+

Pretty sure Gavaskar vs Marshall in 78 isn't the only one to play an ATG before them becoming an ATG or then passed their heydays......
well even at that point Imran was better than Indian bowlers on flat wickets obviously, but I don't really think he was an ATG yet

who are you referencing with the last line?
 

capt_Luffy

International Coach
well even at that point Imran was better than Indian bowlers on flat wickets obviously, but I don't really think he was an ATG yet

who are you referencing with the last line?
Nothing in particular, just saying it's kinda a bit too nitpicky especially since you are including WSC for Viv, but no MCC vs RoW match vs Marshall and Hadlee......
 

Johan

International Captain
Nothing in particular, just saying it's kinda a bit too nitpicky especially since you are including WSC for Viv, but no MCC vs RoW match vs Marshall and Hadlee......
I can do that but if I'm to do that I'd have to go through every tour game or game he played against them, confident?
 

Top