When you say cut it at this level, none of the CA bats are anywhere near the Test team. Tim Ward is the only one picked in the upcoming A gamePat Brown had a good day but I don't think there is much pretence he's going to be anywhere near Test level but Cook bowling tightly and picking up wickets shows that this idea he won't cut it at this level doesn't fly (just pick him, if he fails, then fine).
I partly meant in Australia. Cook averages less than 20 in FC cricket for what is the second best county side and far, far lesser bowlers have been selected ahead of him because of a perception that he's not quick enough. You only know if a guy is good enough if you pick him.When you say cut it at this level, none of the CA bats are anywhere near the Test team. Tim Ward is the only one picked in the upcoming A game
Has clearly improved a lot this year. If he can start turning those 70-80's to tons then there'll definitely be interest once Usman retires.Tim Ward not doing his Ashes chances any harm with 115* in first CA game and now 62* so far in this one. If he does well in the A game could he be a shout for the Windies tour in July?
That's funny when England's incumbent Test spinner Bashir is playing in that "buffet", as is Test bowler Josh TongueSee off Sam Cook, feast into the rest of the buffet bowling.
Tongue is finding his way back from injury. Bashir is a second XI spinner who was brought into Test cricket on vibes, did well in a couple of Tests, but his returns will worsen and he will get the treatment in the Ashes.That's funny when England's incumbent Test spinner Bashir is playing in that "buffet", as is Test bowler Josh Tongue
TMITongue is finding his way back
Doesn't seem to be much in it for the spinners.That's funny when England's incumbent Test spinner Bashir is playing in that "buffet", as is Test bowler Josh Tongue
You've said something along these lines a few times, but nothing in the last decade of Test cricket in Australia would indicate that giving the home side an advantage is a factor in pitch preparation. Ftr I think it should be, it's just not happeningDoesn't seem to be much in it for the spinners.
But it'll be interesting to see if Australia create more spin friendly wickets next year, because they have a clear advantage in Lyon v Bashir (although hoping he's been dropped by then).
Obviously you mean Rehan.If England don't want to go back to Leach or pick Dawson/Carson and have essentially whittled it down to Ahmed or Bashir, then I'd take the former any day or the week. For one, he can bat but I also think he's more likely to produce something out of nothing.