• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Kane Williamson not in league of other elite test batters

Majestic

U19 Captain
I know some will show disagreement with my opinion but to prove my point, I will show the facts that pretty much validates my point.

Nobody has a record as poor as Kane Williamson does away from home vs top sides among all the elite batters that have debuted in this millennium. The obvious names that comes to our mind to debut post 2000 includes the likes of Kumar Sangakkara, Graeme Smith, AB de Villiers, Alastair Cook, Virender Sehwag, Younis Khan, Hashim Amla, Kevin Pietersen, Michael Clarke, Steve Smith, Joe Root and Virat Kohli.

Now, post Younis's retirement, Pakistan have become a really weak team especially at home losing test series to Australia, England and recently worst of all Bangladesh. Windies have been awful at home and Sri Lanka actually have been better at home than Pakistan.

When we look at Williamson's record away from home vs Aus, Eng, Ind, SA, SL, it is pretty poor, averaging 32 with bat.


Now, some may show disagreement with me including SL and excluding Pakistan but even then when we look at his record vs top nations of this era such as Australia, England, India and South Africa, he is simply miles behind Smith, Root and Kohli. You couldn't even find his name actually in the first page.


Williamson as a test batter away from home has poor record than the likes of Pujara, Rahane, Azhar Ali, Angelo Mathews and Asad Shafiq.

In Test cricket while rating players, their record away from home plays such a key role and this is where Williamson, especially vs very good home sides, is miles behind the other world class batters that have debuted in this millennium.
 

Majestic

U19 Captain
Now now, don't get ahead of ourselves. Williamson is absolutely the best batsman at home, in pretty tough home conditions. Definitely in the tier of Root and Kohli.
NZ conditions are not always tough. If its a green pitch, Day 1 is completely bowling friendly but post that pitch gets flat and pretty easy for batting because the role of spinners are very minimal there.
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
NZ conditions are not always tough. If its a green pitch, Day 1 is completely bowling friendly but post that pitch gets flat and pretty easy for batting because the role of spinners are very minimal there.
KW has did very well in plenty of tough home conditions. Certainly important since NZ plays much less games in India or England, let alone SA; compared to other top tier teams.
 

Majestic

U19 Captain
KW has did very well in plenty of tough home conditions. Certainly important since NZ plays much less games in India or England, let alone SA; compared to other top tier teams.
What about away conditions? Everyone is a beast at home conditions, although he has poor record vs Australia at home also.

Btw, he has played clutch knocks at home but NZ are usually very good for batting once the new ball stops swinging. You probably watch Indian games and India have got tough conditions, not everyone else.

Williamson's away record as suggested in the OP is very poor and the worst among all elite batters, including the likes of Pietersen, Clarke etc. Even the second tier Asian batters have better away record vs top teams than Williamson.
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
What about away conditions? Everyone is a beast at home conditions, although he has poor record vs Australia at home also.

Btw, he has played clutch knocks at home but NZ are usually very good for batting once the new ball stops swinging. You probably watch Indian games and India have got tough conditions, not everyone else.

Williamson's away record as suggested in the OP is very poor and the worst among all elite batters, including the likes of Pietersen, Clarke etc. Even the second tier Asian batters have better away record vs top teams than Williamson.
LATD
 

Coronis

International Coach
NZ conditions are not always tough. If its a green pitch, Day 1 is completely bowling friendly but post that pitch gets flat and pretty easy for batting because the role of spinners are very minimal there.
Lyon would disagree
 

Majestic

U19 Captain
Let's agree to disagree. I think you're really downplaying KW's home scores, as well the fact that since 2013, he played a single series each in India and England.
No wonder his overall record is so good, he plays minnow nations regularly and bash them but a pretty mediocre performance away from home.
 

Top