Top allrounders to debut in the 21st century.

[Kenneth Viljoen]

Holder is a terrible bowler though

Holder has got 8 5-fors and 1 10 wicket haul , from the all rounders who you had above him only Shakib , Jadeja , Ashwin and Philander took more 5+ wickets in a match .

Then you filter in he's got 3 test tons and 14 test 50's, plays for a weak side and juggled captaincy..

Plus Holder had an insane mini peak with bat and ball during 2018 & 2019..

680 runs @42.50
53 test wickets @14.23

2021 was his last great year in Tests with the ball though , 22 test wickets @22.77, given the lack of proper all rounders who could make their side as a batter or bowler I would say Holder has to be top 7.

 

[Fuller Pilch]

Okay. He's a terrible bowler in NZ and Australia.

I still think CDG, Oram, Hafeez, and Watson are ahead of him as they are all much much better with the bat and adequate with the ball.

 

[sayon basak]

Yes think ashwin underachived with bat

And holder underachieved with both.

 

[Coronis]

Comes down to Shakib and Jadeja. Shakib wins. One of 3 players to score a century and take a 10’fer in the same match.

 

[Majestic]

Jadeja
Stokes
Shakib

That's top 3. Rest are more like bowling all rounders or batting all rounders. Ashwin is arguably a better test cricketer than any of these all rounders though.

 

[Xix2565]

Rest are more like bowling all rounders or batting all rounders.

So? They're still all rounders. Why this separation in an overall rating?

 

[Migara]

Shakib
Jadeja
Stokes
Holder
Green

would be my top picks as AR.

Players wise Ashwin, Shakib and Jadeja are the most impactful.

 

[Molehill]

Surely, Broad needs a mention here. Yeah, his batting tailed off, but he was a real all rounder to begin with as his Test ton proved. Could also include Swann too who would easily have been good enough to bat 8 were he not behind Bresnan and Broad.