PlayerComparisons
International Vice-Captain
.
Yeah but Kallis is top 3.Hobbs is a top 10 cricketer
Nah thats ridiculous frankly. He would possibly be if he were unquestionably the best bat of his era on top of his bowling and catching, but he ain't close.Yeah but Kallis is top 3.
Do you rate Kallis ahead of Sachin or Imran?Yeah but Kallis is top 3.
Wait, was Imran the best bowler of his era?Nah thats ridiculous frankly. He would possibly be if he were unquestionably the best bat of his era on top of his bowling and catching, but he ain't close.
I would say Imran was much closer to Hadlee than Kallis to Lara(Marshall and Sachin the best of their eras, but even there).Wait, was Imran the best bowler of his era?
Becuse this argument is incredibly inconsistent.
Its close, if lillee, hadlee and west Indies didn't exist, then he would be the greatest bowler of his time.Wait, was Imran the best bowler of his era?
Becuse this argument is incredibly inconsistent.
You really want me to respond?Wait, was Imran the best bowler of his era?
Becuse this argument is incredibly inconsistent.
You do know the statement was he wasn't the undisputed best bat of his era.I would say Imran was much closer to Hadlee than Kallis to Lara(Marshall and Sachin the best of their eras, but even there).
YesDo you rate Kallis ahead of Sachin or Imran?
It’s simple for me. I rate Kallis amongst the top 15-16 bats, and Imran amongst the top 5-6 bowlers. Further I value Imran’s batting over Kallis’ bowling. But then I agree we agreed to disagree about Immy long time back(during the Ambrose comparisons).You do know the statement was he wasn't the undisputed best bat of his era.
Kallis was 4th, I don't see how that's different...
Imran in the 70's was well behind a host of players, 80's 3rd, and one could make an argument for others.
Kallis doesn't get in my top 10.
Well just a reminder, Kallis outside the top 10 is also the majority CW view. I'm no outlier.
Yeah but you are a Kallis outlier in general here which is why you saying that was such a Captain Obvious statement.Well just a reminder, Kallis outside the top 10 is also the majority CW view. I'm no outlier.