Which ATG bats and bowlers would have notably different records if they served in a different team

[subshakerz]

As the title suggests. If you switched the home country team of an ATG, assuming the same set of skills, which players would have marked differences in their career records and which players would be more or less the same.

 

[Coronis]

All of them. Next.

 

[TheJediBrah]

These are getting worse

 

[OverratedSanity]

Crybaby Aussies triggered by Asian man asking uncomfortable but necessary questions. Typical.

 

[TheJediBrah]

Disappointing anti-Australian racism on display

 

[Burgey]

Patient but exasperated Aussies triggered by Asian man asking transparent and agenda-laden but unnecessary questions to try to explain that region's players historical second-ratedeness. Typical.

Yeah

 

[Victor Ian]

Imran waqar and Akram never play a test because they get booted at club level for tampering.

Sachin, still a great, holds no records because he has to prove himself for many years before debut.

With no clouds to help him, Anderson moves to Melbourne for a different swinging scene.

 

[subshakerz]

Yeah

On the contrary, we are trying to gauge the degree to which 'secondratedness' is a consequence of player ability versus external factors.

 

[subshakerz]

Imran waqar and Akram never play a test because they get booted at club level for tampering.

On the contrary, thanks to them, tampering is legalized by the ICC years ahead of its time.

 

[OverratedSanity]

Sandpaper experts lecturing the cricket world on why tampering is bad lmao couldn't make this up. Your greatest spinner is a drug cheat, and your current best batsman and bowler are proven convicted/disgraced tamperers. Crybabies.

 

[OverratedSanity]

Disappointing anti-Australian racism

No such thing

 

[TheJediBrah]

Sandpaper experts lecturing the cricket world on why tampering is bad lmao couldn't make this up. Your greatest spinner is a drug cheat, and your current best batsman and bowler are proven convicted/disgraced tamperers. Crybabies.

Dravid and Sachin are objectively tamperers more than either but cry more

 

[subshakerz]

Dravid and Sachin are objectively tamperers more than either but cry more

They deserve leeway it was just after the matchfixing scandal after all, they were going through a lot.

 

[OverratedSanity]

Edit :spark

 

[Nintendo]

Imran waqar and Akram never play a test because they get booted at club level for tampering.

Sachin, still a great, holds no records because he has to prove himself for many years before debut.

With no clouds to help him, Anderson moves to Melbourne for a different swinging scene.

Wrong. Wasim becomes the new Charlie turner as his catches are taken. By my calculations he ends up averaging 10 with the ball, and because he never has to develop reverse swing he instead focuses more on batting and also averages 40 with the bat.

 

[TheJediBrah]

Wrong. Wasim becomes the new Charlie turner as his catches are taken. By my calculations he ends up averaging 10 with the ball, and because he never has to develop reverse swing he instead focuses more on batting and also averages 40 with the bat.

This is what subshakerz has been waiting for

/thread

 

[subshakerz]

Sehwag ends up averaging a fair bit higher if he plays for Australia as opener, and in the middle order averaging roughly in the same for Eng, SA or NZ.

 

[centurymaker]

Imran waqar and Akram never play a test because they get booted at club level for tampering.

Sachin, still a great, holds no records because he has to prove himself for many years before debut.

With no clouds to help him, Anderson moves to Melbourne for a different swinging scene.

Playing for Aus, Tendulkar gets to play 12 tests a year in his prime as opposed to playing 7 tests a year in his prime and ends up holding records by an even greater margin. (Ponting broke into the side at 20/21 so Tendulkar gets in around 19).

Akram develops into an even better bowler than McGrath with the slips support and what not.

Not so sure about Anderson. lol

 

[subshakerz]

Playing for Aus, Tendulkar gets to play 12 tests a year in his prime as opposed to playing 7 tests a year in his prime and ends up holding records by an even greater margin. (Ponting broke into the side at 20/21 so Tendulkar gets in around 19).

Akram develops into an even better bowler than McGrath with the slips support and what not.

Not so sure about Anderson. lol

Anderson become a better version of Srinath.

 

[Coronis]

Gilchrist debuts at least 4 years earlier and ends up averaging 50+. Causes a riot if he’s playing for certain countries and walks during an important match.