Keith Miller vs Vivian Richards

[ma1978]

Miller clearly makes the post war second xi, with a case for first xi. Viv in my view makes the first xi with an argument for Smith replacing him.

firstxi

Hutton
Gavaskar
Lara
tendulkar
Richards
Sobers
Gikchrist
Imran
Hadlee
Marshall
Warne

second xi

Greenidge
Graeme Smith
Ponting
Steve Smith
Chappell
Miller
Botham
Knott
Mcgrath
Steyn
Murali

both are in some pretty elitte company

 

[number11]

Not clearly. Many put Kallis ahead of Imran, and some even put him ahead of Sobers.

Please name credible experts who do that. And name a few as you said "many". Thanks.

 

[Fuller Pilch]

Please name credible experts who do that. And name a few as you said "many". Thanks.

I never mentioned "experts", but if you want "many" type in "Youtube: greatest allrounder" and read the comments

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Getting riled up at facing the fact that Keith Miller is a post war Chris Cairns… or Ravi Shastri

Do we need a Keith Miller vs Ravi Shastri poll?

 

[number11]

I never mentioned "experts", but if you want "many" type in "Youtube: greatest allrounder" and read the comments

Your post implied that considered opinion shares your view. When asked to substantiate you shifted to "youtube comments".

YT comments obviously skew young, and are not a credible source. What a thing to say.

 

[Coronis]

Your post implied that considered opinion shares your view. When asked to substantiate you shifted to "youtube comments".

YT comments obviously skew young, and are not a credible source. What a thing to say.

Literally all he said was “many” mate. Many = more people. Don’t be pissy cos you misinterpreted someone.

 

[OverratedSanity]

Your post implied that considered opinion shares your view. When asked to substantiate you shifted to "youtube comments".

YT comments obviously skew young, and are not a credible source. What a thing to say.

You can look through the all time XIs that cricketers pick on the Lord's youtube channel. Basically everyone picks Kallis and names him as the greatest all rounder.

 

[kyear2]

You can look through the all time XIs that cricketers pick on the Lord's youtube channel. Basically everyone picks Kallis and names him as the greatest all rounder.

Just a quick search on YouTube, not only in Kallis the greatest all rounder, but Sachin is the greatest batsman and top 2 or 3 player ever. Jimmy Anderson is better than any of the West Indies Quartets, including Marshall and Kholi is seen at top 10 batsmen ever.

I just cannot...